Proving customary norms: Ontology and evidence in international law

• Autores: Piero Mattei-Gentili
• Localización: Quaestio facti. Revista internacional sobre razonamiento probatorio, ISSN-e 2604-6202, Nº. 11, 2026, págs. 89-121
• Idioma: inglés
• DOI: 10.33115/udg_bib/qf.i11.23272
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo
• Resumen

  • This article addresses the epistemological and conceptual challenges involved in proving customary norms in international law. It argues that confusion surrounding usus and opinio jurisstems from a failure to distinguish between the ontology of customary norms and the determina-tion of their existence. Drawing on legal epistemology, social norm theory, and analytical legal phi-losophy, the article conceptualizes customary norms as products of socially constituted structures grounded in shared normative expectations. Proving opinio juris does not require showing that States regard their conduct as legally mandatory, but rather that second-order normative expecta-tions are manifested through patterns of practice. The article defends a dual inferential model — inductive reasoning to establish usus, complemented by abductive reasoning to infer opinio juris— and proposes a narrative coherence test as a qualitative supplement to the preponderance standard.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Accatino, Daniela (2014). «Atomismo y holismo en la justificación probatoria». Isonomía, 40, 17–59.
  • Akehurst, M. (1975). «Custom as a Source of International Law». British Yearbook of International Law, 47(1), 1–53.
  • Alchourrón, Carlos & Bulygin, Eugenio (1981). «The Expressive Conception of Norms». En Risto Hilpinen (ed.), New Essays in Deontic Logic....
  • Bannelier, Karine, Christakis, Theodore & Heathcote, Sarah (eds.) (2012). The ICJ and the Evolution of International Law. Routledge.
  • Bederman, David (2010). Custom as a Source of Law. Cambridge University Press.
  • Beham, Markus (2022). «Schrödinger’s Custom». En Panos Merkouris, Jörg Kammerhofer & Noora Arajärvi (eds.), Theory, Practice, and Interpretation...
  • Bentham, Jeremy (2010). Of the Limits of the Penal Branch of Jurisprudence (Philip Schofield ed.). Clarendon Press.
  • Bentham, Jeremy (1977). A Comment on the Commentaries and A Fragment of Government (J. H. Burns & H. L. A. Hart eds.). Clarendon Press.
  • Bicchieri, Cristina (2006). The Grammar of Society. The Nature and Dynamics of Social Norms. Cambridge University Press.
  • Bicchieri, Cristina (2014). «Norms, Conventions and the Problem of Expectations». En Nancy Cartwright & Eleonora Montuschi (eds.), Philosophy...
  • Bicchieri, Cristina (2017). Norms in the Wild. Oxford University Press.
  • Bobbio, Norberto (2010). La consuetudine come fatto normativo. G. Giappichelli Editore.
  • Brady, Michael S. & Fricker, Miranda (eds.) (2016). The Epistemic Life of Groups. Oxford University Press.
  • Brandom, Robert (1994). Making it Explicit. Harvard University Press.
  • Brandom, Robert (2000). Articulating Reasons. Harvard University Press.
  • Brennan, Geoffrey, Eriksson, Lina, Goodin, Robert & Southwood, Nicholas (2013). Explaining Norms. Oxford University Press.
  • Bulygin, Eugenio (1991). «Algunas consideraciones sobre los sistemas jurídicos». Doxa. Cuadernos de Filosofía del Derecho, 9, 257–279.
  • Canale, Damiano (2008). «Paradossi della consuetudine giuridica». En Silvia Zorzetto (ed.), La consuetudine giuridica. Teoria, storia, ambiti...
  • Cartwright, Nancy & Montuschi, Eleonora (eds.) (2014). Philosophy of Social Science. Oxford University Press.
  • Celano, Bruno (2010). Fatti istituzionali, consuetudini e convenzioni. Aracne.
  • Chiassoni, Pierluigi (2008). «Tre buoni filosofi contro i cattivi costumi». En Silvia Zorzetto (ed.), La consuetudine giuridica. Teoria, storia,...
  • Chwe, Michael S. (2001). Culture, Coordination, and Common Knowledge. Princeton University Press.
  • Collins, Stephanie & Lawford-Smith, Holly (2016). «The Transfer of Duties. From Individuals to States and Back Again». En Michael S. Brady...
  • D’Amato, Anthony (1971). The Concept of Custom in International Law. Cornell University Press.
  • D’Amato, Anthony (1987). «Trashing Customary International Law». The American Journal of International Law, 81(1), 101–105.
  • d’Aspremont, Jean (2011). Formalism and the Sources of International Law. Oxford University Press.
  • d’Aspremont, Jean (2022). «The Custom-Making Moment in Customary International Law». En Panos Merkouris, Jörg Kammerhofer & Noora Arajärvi...
  • Del Mar, Kathleen (2012). «The International Court of Justice and Standards of Proof». En Karine Bannelier, Theodore Christakis & Sarah...
  • Ferrer Beltrán, Jordi (2005). Prueba y verdad en el derecho (2.ª ed.). Marcial Pons.
  • Ferrer Beltrán, Jordi (2007). La valoración racional de la prueba. Marcial Pons.
  • Ferrer Beltrán, Jordi (2021). Prueba sin convicción. Marcial Pons.
  • García-Carpintero, Manuel (1996). Las palabras, las ideas y las cosas. Ariel.
  • Gardner, John (2012). Law as a Leap of Faith. Oxford University Press.
  • Goldman, Alvin (1999). Knowledge in a Social World. Clarendon Press.
  • González Lagier, Daniel (2005). Quaestio facti, Vol. I. Palestra Editores.
  • González Lagier, Daniel (2022). Quaestio facti, Vol. II. Palestra Editores.
  • Guala, Francesco (2013). «The Normativity of Lewis Conventions». Synthese, 190, 3107–3122.
  • Guala, Francesco (2016). Understanding Institutions. Princeton University Press.
  • Guastini, Riccardo (2011). Interpretare e argomentare. Giuffrè Editore.
  • Guastini, Riccardo (2018). «Dos concepciones de normas». Revus, 35.
  • Haack, Susan (2014). Evidence Matters. Cambridge University Press.
  • Hart, H. L. A. (1994). The Concept of Law (2nd ed.). Clarendon Press.
  • Hart, H. L. A. (2013). «Discretion». Harvard Law Review, 127(2), 652–665.
  • Hilpinen, Risto (ed.) (1981). New Essays in Deontic Logic. Reidel Publishing Company.
  • Johnson, Katie (2021). «The Nature and Context of Rules and the Identification of Customary International Law». The European Journal of International...
  • Jones, Todd (2011). «Uncovering the “Cultural Meaning”: Problems and Solutions». En Daniel Steer & Francesco Guala (eds.), The Philosophy...
  • Kelsen, Hans (1949). General Theory of Law and State. Harvard University Press.
  • Kelsen, Hans (1956). Principles of International Law. Rinehart & Company.
  • Kirgis, Frederic (1987). «Custom on a Sliding Scale». The American Journal of International Law, 81(1), 146–151.
  • Kunz, Josef (1953). «The Nature of Customary International Law». The American Journal of International Law, 47(4), 662–669.
  • Lewis, David K. (2002). Convention. Blackwell Publishing.
  • Lipton, Peter (2000). «Inference to the Best Explanation». En William H. Newton-Smith (ed.), A Companion to Philosophy of Science. Blackwell...
  • Marmor, Andrei (2009). Social Conventions. From Language to Law. Princeton University Press.
  • Mattei-Gentili, Piero (2020a). «Social Facts & the Semantic Conception of Norms. Customary Norms as a Test of Ontology». Phenomenology...
  • Mattei-Gentili, Piero (2020b). «The Quest for the Opinio Juris: An Analysis of Customary Law, From Hart’s Social Rules to Expectations and...
  • Mattei-Gentili, Piero (2024). «Normas como significados. Una revisión al debate sobre ontología de normas y teoría jurídica». Doxa. Cuadernos...
  • Mattei-Gentili, Piero (2026). La normatividad de la costumbre. Marcial Pons.
  • Merkouris, Panos, Kammerhofer, Jörg & Arajärvi, Noora (eds.) (2022). Theory, Practice, and Interpretation of Customary International Law....
  • Moreso, José Juan, Navarro, Pablo & Redondo, María Cristina (2002). Conocimiento jurídico y determinación normativa. Palestra Editores.
  • Navarro, Pablo E. (2005). «Acerca de la inevitabilidad de la interpretación». Isonomía, 22, 99–123.
  • Newton-Smith, William H. (ed.) (2000). A Companion to Philosophy of Science. Blackwell Publishers.
  • Perreau-Saussine, Amanda & Murphy, James B. (eds.) (2007). The Nature of Customary Law. Cambridge University Press.
  • Postema, Gerald (2007). «Custom in International Law: A Normative Account». En Amanda Perreau-Saussine & James B. Murphy (eds.), The Nature...
  • Postema, Gerald (2012). «Custom, Normative Practice, and the Law». Duke Law Journal, 62, 707–738.
  • Raz, Joseph (1990). The Concept of a Legal System (2nd ed.). Clarendon Press.
  • Roberts, Anthea (2001). «Traditional and Modern Approaches to Customary International Law: A Reconciliation». The American Journal of International...
  • Searle, John (1969). Speech Acts. Cambridge University Press.
  • Sender, Omri & Wood, Michael (2024). Identification of Customary International Law. Oxford University Press.
  • Shapiro, Scott (2006). «What is the Internal Point of View». Fordham Law Review, 75(3), 1157–1170.
  • Steer, Daniel & Guala, Francesco (eds.) (2011). The Philosophy of Social Science Reader. Routledge.
  • Sunstein, Cass (2019). How Change Happens. The MIT Press.
  • Talmon, Stefan (2015). «Determining Customary International Law: The ICJ’s Methodology between Induction, Deduction and Assertion». The European...
  • Tams, Christian (2015). «Meta-Custom and the Court: A Study in Judicial Law-Making». The Law and Practice of International Courts and Tribunals,...
  • Taruffo, Michele (2008). La prueba (trad. L. Manríquez & J. Ferrer Beltrán). Marcial Pons.
  • Twining, William (2006). Rethinking Evidence (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press.
  • Ullmann-Margalit, Edna (1977). The Emergence of Norms. Clarendon Press.
  • Vernengo, Roberto (1976). Curso de teoría general del derecho (2nd ed.). Cooperadora de Derecho y Ciencias Sociales.
  • Williamson, Timothy (2002). Knowledge and Its Limits. Oxford University Press.
  • Zorzetto, Silvia (ed.) (2008). La consuetudine giuridica. Teoria, storia, ambiti disciplinari. Edizioni ETS.