El debate esta servido. La transparencia en los laudos arbitrales: Un tribunal de apelación o un tribunal internacional de inversiones

• Autores: Nayiber Febles Pozo
• Localización: RDUNED. Revista de derecho UNED, ISSN-e 2255-3436, ISSN 1886-9912, Nº. 30, 2022, págs. 403-474
• Idioma: español
• DOI: 10.5944/rduned.30.2022.36854
• Títulos paralelos:
  • The debate is served. transparency in arbitration awards: An appeal court or an international investment court
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo
• Dialnet Métricas: 1 Cita
• Resumen
  • español

    En el trabajo se analiza la transparencia en los laudos arbitrales y con ella, la necesidad de una consistencia y coherencia de las decisiones a través del precedente arbitral a partir de un profundo análisis de casos. Se propone un sistema multilateral de solución de controversias: Tribunal Internacional de Inversión o Tribunal Permanente de Apelación.

  • English

    The paper analyzes transparency in arbitration awards and with it, the need for consistency and coherence of decisions through arbitration precedent based on a deep analysis of cases. A multilateral dispute settlement system is proposed: International Investment Court or Permanent Court of Appeal.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Álvarez Ávila, G., «Las características del arbitraje del CIADI». Anuario Mexicano de Derecho Internacional, 2002.
  • Bentolila, D., «Hacia una jurisprudencia arbitral en el arbitraje internacional de inversiones», Anuario Mexicano de Derecho Internacional,...
  • Berger, K.P., «International Arbitration Practice and the Unidroit Principles of International Commercial Contracts», AM. J. COMP. L., Vol....
  • Bhatia, V., Candlin, Ch., Sharma, R., «Confidentiality and Integrity in. International Commercial Arbitration Practice», Arbitration, Vol....
  • Blavi, F., «A Case in Favour of Publicly Available Awards in International Commercial Arbitration: Transparency v Confidentiality», INT’L...
  • Born, G., International Commercial Arbitration, Kluwer Law International, Segunda Edición, The Netherlands, 2014.
  • Brenowitz, S., «Deadly Secrecy: «The Erosion of public information under private justice», Ohio Student Journal on Dispute Resolu¬tion, No....
  • Carmody, M., «Overturning the Presumption of Confidentiality: Should the UNCITRAL Rules on Transparency be applied to InernacionalCommercial...
  • Carmody, M., «Towards a Political Theory of International Courts and Tribu¬nals», BJIL., Vol. 24, 2006.
  • Carmody, M., «Reputation and Reality in the ICSID Annulment Process: Understanding the Distinction Between Annulment and Appeal», ICSID Foreign...
  • Cheng, T.H., «Precedent and Control in Investment Treaty Arbitr¬tion», Fordham International Law Journal, Vol. 30, No. 4, 2006.
  • Commission, J.P., «Precedent in Investment Treaty Arbitration: A Ci¬tation Analysis of a Developing Jurisprudence», JIA, Vol. 24, 2007.
  • Crawford, J., «Similarity of Issues in Disputes Arising under the Same or Similarly Drafted Investment Treaties», in Gaillard, E., Banifatemi,...
  • Dessemontet, F., «Arbitration and confidentiality», ARIA, No. 7, 1996, p. 318.
  • Dugan, CH.F., Wallace, D.Jr., Rubins, N., Sabahi, B., Investor-State Arbitration, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2008.
  • Fauchald, O.K., «The Legal Reasoning of ICSID Tribunals — An Empirical Analysis», European Journal of International Law, Vol. 19, 2008.
  • Feldman, M., «Investment Arbitration Appellate Mechanism Options: Consistency, Accuracy, and Balance of Power», ICSID Review, Vol. 32, No....
  • Fernández Arroyo, D.P., «El auge del arbitraje frente al debate sobre su legitimidad» en Jornadas sobre The Transformation of Enforce¬ment,...
  • Franck, S.D., «Foreign Direct Investment, Investment Treaty Arbitration, and the Rule of Law», MGBDLJ, Vol. 19, 2007.
  • Frimpong Oppong, R., Niro, L.C., «Enforcing Judgments of International Courts in National Courts», Journal of International Dispute Settlement,...
  • García-Bolívar, O.E., «La crisis del derecho internacional de inversiones extranjeras: propuestas de reforma», Revista de la Secretaría del...
  • García Da Fonseca, R., De Luizi Correia, A., «The Limits of Confidentiality in arbitration: A Brazilian perspective», Y.B. ON INT’L ARB.,...
  • Henkel, CH., «The Work-Product Doctrine as a Means toward a Judicially Enforceable Duty of Confidentiality in International Com¬mercial Arbitration»,...
  • Hobér, K., Selected Writings on Investment Treaty Arbitration, 1st Ed., Studentlitteratur, Lund, 2013.
  • Hodges, P., «The Perils of Complete Transparency in International Arbitration — Should Parties Be Exposed to the Glare of Public¬ity?», PARIS...
  • Ishikawa, T., «Keeping Interpretation in Investment Treaty Arbitration ‘‘on Track’’: The Role of States Parties» in Kalicki, J., Joubin-Bret,...
  • Karton, J.D.H., «Reform of Investor-State Dispute Settlement: Lessons from International Uniform Law», Queen’s University Faculty of Law,...
  • Kaufmann-Kohler, G., Potestà, M., «Can the Mauritius Convention serve as a model for the reform of Investor-State arbitration in connection...
  • Kaufmann-Kohler. G., «Annulment of ICSID Awards in Contracts and Treaty Arbitrations: Are there Differences?», in Gaillard, E., Banifatemi,...
  • Kim, D., «The Annulment Committee’s Role in Multiplying Inconsistency in ICSID Arbitration: The Need to Move Away from an Annulment-Based...
  • Leben, CH., «Quelques réflexions théoriques à propos des contrats d’Etat», in AA.VV.: Souveraineté étatique et marchés internationaux à la...
  • López Linaldi, L.A.: La necesidad de crear un órgano de apelación para arbitrajes inversionista-estado en CIADI, Revista de Derecho Económico...
  • López Rodríguez, A.M., «El Sistema de Tribunales de Inversión. Posibles incompatibilidades con el Derecho europeo», Cuadernos Europeos de...
  • Lowe R., «Investment arbitration claims could be traded like derivatives», IBA Global Insigh, 2013.
  • Lozada Pimiento, N.E., «El mecanismo de anulación de los laudos arbitrales del ciadi: qué es y para dónde va», Revista de Derecho Privado,...
  • Malmsten, J., «Informal Reliance on Previously Rendered Awards. An Efficient Means to Promote Consistency on the MFN Question?», UPPSALA Universitet,...
  • Mourre, A., «The Case for the Publication of Arbitral Awards», in Malatesta, A., Sali, R. (Ed.): The Rise of Transparence in International...
  • Mourre, A., «Precedent and Confidentiality in International Commercial Arbi¬tration: The Case for the Publication of Arbitral Awards», in...
  • Oglindă, B., «The Principle of Confidentiality in Arbitration: Application and Limitations of the Principle», PERSPS. OF BUS. L, J., Vol....
  • Pascual Vives, F.J., «La institución del amicus curiae y el arbitraje de inversiones», Anuario español de derecho internacional, Vol. 27,...
  • Polanco Lazo, R., «Transparencia y Derechos de terceros en arbitrajes internacionales sobre inversión extranjera», Revista de Derecho Económico,...
  • Posner, E.A., Yoo, J.C., «Judicial Independence in International Tribunals», California Law. Rev. Vol. 93, No. 1, 2005.
  • Reuben, R.C., «Constitutional Gravity: A Unitary Theory of Alternative Dispute Resolution and Public Civil Justice», UCLA L. REV., Vol. 47,...
  • Roberts, A., «Power and Persuasion in Investment Treaty Interpretation: The Dual Role of States», AJIL, Vol. 104, 2010.
  • Rodríguez Vicente, M., «¿Es necesario un tribunal multilateral de inversiones?», Boletín Económico de ICE, 2017.
  • Schreuer, C., «Diversity and Harmonization of Treaty Interpretation in Investment Arbitration», Transnational Dispute Management, Vol. 3,...
  • Schreuer, C., The ICISD Convention: A Commentary, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, Second Ed., 2009.
  • Ten Cate, I.M., «The costs of consistency: precedent in investment treaty arbitration», CJTL, Vol. 51, 2013.
  • Torterola, I., «Transparencia y publicidad en el arbitraje de inversión», Revista Ecuatoriana de Arbitraje, 2015.
  • Walsh, T.W., «Substantive Review of ICSID Awards: Is the Desire for Accuracy Sufficient to Compromise Finality», BJIL., Vol. 24, No. 2, 2006.
  • Weidemaier, W.M.C., «Towards a Theory of Precedent in Arbitration», William and Mary Law. Review, Vol. 51, No. 5, 2010.