The politicisation of the UK civil service: causes, manifestations, and evolutions

• Autores: Lee Marsons, Yseult Marique
• Localización: Revista catalana de dret públic, ISSN 1885-5709, ISSN-e 1885-8252, Nº. 65, 2022 (Ejemplar dedicado a: Reptes de l'ocupació pública)
• Idioma: inglés
• DOI: 10.2436/rcdp.i65.2022.3879
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo
• Resumen

  • The UK civil service is shaped by three principles – permanency, impartiality and integrity. These principles explain the recurring tensions between the civil service and their ministers, who are ultimately accountable for the civil service. Since the early 1980s, UK governments have sought to reform the civil service to make it more compliant with their shortterm political agendas. Attempts at weakening the civil service leads to political conflicts taking a range of expressions:

    1) political rhetoric from ministers about the quality and intentions of civil servants; 2) the terms and conditions of employment for civil servants; 3) competition from special advisers; 4) political control of senior appointments by the executive, and 5) being asked to carry out tasks which by their nature are highly politically contentious, such as writing reports on controversial subjects of intense public interest. The overall result of this tension seems to backfire, however.

    Politicians are increasingly little trusted by the UK citizens, while the guarantees of permanency, impartiality and integrity seem to bear their fruit in producing civil servants able and willing to stand their ground against political expediency

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Bew, Paul. (2015). The Committee on Standards in Public Life: Twenty Years of the Nolan Principles 1995-2015. The Political Quarterly, 86-3,...
  • Bogdanor, Vernon. (2003.) The Civil Service. In Vernon Bogdanor (Ed.), The British Constitution in the Twentieth Century (pp. 237-279). Oxford...
  • Chapman, Richard A. (2004). The Civil Service Commission 1855–1991. A Bureau Biography. Routledge.
  • Chisholm, Alex. (2022, February 7). We’re Levelling Up Careers in the Civil Service. Blog Civil Service.
  • Dargie, Charlotte, & Locke, Rachel. (1999). The British Senior Civil Service. In Edward Page and Vincent Wright (Ed.), Bureaucratic Elites...
  • Doig, Alan. (1996). From Lynskey to Nolan: The Corruption of British Politics and Public Service? Journal of Law and Society, 23:1, 36-56.
  • Farooq, Arfah. (2021, March 10). Introduction to the No.10 Fellowship Programme. Blog Government Digital Service.
  • Government and civil service. (2022). Public Law, Jul, 472-473.
  • Halsbury’s Laws of England. (2014). Volume 20.
  • Hazell, Robert. (2019). Improving Parliamentary Scrutiny of Public Appointments. Parliamentary Affairs, 72:2, 223-244.
  • Leyland, Peter. (forthcoming). The Civil Service UK Style: Facing up to Change? In Adam Krzywoń, Cristina Frankel-Haeberle and Karl-Peter...
  • Maer, Lucinda, & McCaffrey, Ray. (2018). Special Advisers. House of Commons Library, Number 3813.
  • Maer, Lucinda, & Ryan-White, Georgina. (2017). Pre-appointment hearings. House of Commons Library, Number 04387.
  • Morgan, Tamsin. (2018, August 30). The Places for Growth Programme: driving growth across the UK. Blog Civil Service.
  • Oliver, Dawn. (1995). Standards of Conduct in Public Life. What Standards? Public Law, 4, 497-503.
  • Parris, Henry. (1969). Constitutional Bureaucracy – The Development of British Central Administration since the Eighteenth Century. George...
  • Sandberg, Russell. (2006). A Whitehall farce? Defining and conceptualising the British Civil Service. Public Law, 4, 653-663.
  • Thomas, Alex. (2021, December 9). It is not right to appoint a politician to lead the Civil Service Commission. Institute for Government blog.