Y sonaron las trompetas a las puertas de Jericó... en forma de sentencia del Bundesverfassungsgericht

• Autores: Pablo J. Martín Rodríguez
• Localización: Revista General de Derecho Europeo, ISSN-e 1696-9634, Nº. 52, 2020
• Idioma: español
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Dialnet Métricas: 13 Citas
• Resumen

  • El 5 de mayo de 2020, la Sala Segunda del Tribunal Constitucional Federal Alemán dictó una sentencia en la que declara ultra vires tanto las correspondientes Decisiones del Banco Central Europeo que establecen el Programa de adquisición de títulos de deuda públicos como la Sentencia del Tribunal de Justicia en el asunto Weiss y otros que había confirmado su validez. El presente estudio analiza críticamente este severo pronunciamiento del Tribunal de Karlsruhe ilustrando sus contradicciones y tratando de identificar sus posibles consecuencias.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • TAVARES LANCEIRO, R., “Op-Ed: “The Portuguese Constitutional Court judgment 422/2020 – a ‘Solange’ moment?”, blog [EU Law Live], 24/7/2020.
  • Editorial, “On the Lissabon-Urteil: democracy and a democratic paradox”, European Constitutional Law Review, vol. 5, 2009, p. 341.
  • AVBELJ, M., “The Federal Constitutional Court Rules for a Bright Future of Constitutional Pluralism”, German Law Journal, vol. 21, núm. 1,...
  • BOBIĆ, A., “Developments in The EU-German Judicial Love Story: The Right To Be Forgotten II”, ambos en German Law Journal, vol. 21, núm. 1,...
  • ZILLER, J., “The unbearable heaviness of the German constitutional judge. On the judgment of the Second Chamber of the German Federal Constitutional...
  • VITERBO, A., “The PSPP Judgment of the German Federal Constitutional Court: Throwing Sand in the Wheels of the European Central Bank”, European...
  • SARMIENTO, D., “Op-Ed: An Infringement Action against Germany after its Constitutional Court’s ruling in Weiss? The Long Term and the Short...
  • POLI, S., “The German Federal Court and its first ultra vires review: a critique and a preliminary assessment of its consequences”, Eurojus,...
  • POLI, S., & CISOTTA, R., “The German Federal Constitutional Court’s Exercise of Ultra Vires Review and the Possibility to Open an Infringement...
  • LINDEBOOM, J., “Is the Primacy of EU Law Based on the Equality of the Member States? A Comment on the CJEU’s Press Release Following the PSPP...
  • GRIMM, D., “A Long Time Coming”, German Law Journal, vol. 21, núm. 5, 2020, pp. 944-949. doi:10.1017/glj.2020.55.
  • SIMON, S. y RATHKE, H., “<>. Why?”, German Law Journal, vol. 21, núm. 5, 2020, pp. 950-955, doi:10.1017/glj.2020.65
  • CAPITANT, D., “L’arrêt de la Cour constitutionnelle fédérale du 5 mai 2020 relative au PSPP (2 BvR 859/15) – La Cour constitutionnelle fédérale...
  • FEICHTNER, I., “The German Constitutional Court’s PSPP Judgment: Impediment and Impetus for the Democratization of Europe”, German Law Journal,...
  • SARMIENTO, D. y WEILER, J.H.H., “Op-Ed: The EU Judiciary After Weiss Weiss: Proposing A New Mixed Chamber of the Court of Justice”, blog [EU...
  • CRUZ VILAÇA, J.L., “O acórdão do tribunal constitucional alemão e o tribunal de justiça – cooperação judicial ou diálogo de surdos?”, CERIDAP...
  • WENDEL, M., “Paradoxes of Ultra-Vires Review: A Critical Review of the PSPP Decision and Its Initial Reception”, German Law Journal, vol....
  • ELEFTHERIADIS, P., “Germany’s Failing Court”, [VerfBlog] 18/5/2020, doi: 10.17176/20200519-013420-0.
  • CARNEIRO, R.L., “The transition from quantity to quality: A neglected causal mechanism in accounting for social evolution”, PNAS, vol. 97,...
  • SAÍNZ DE VICUÑA Y BARROSO, A., “La política monetaria del BCE ante el Tribunal Constitucional Federal Alemán: la Sentencia de 21 de junio...
  • GALETTA, D.-U. y ZILLER, J., “Karlsruhe über alles? La insoportable pesadez del juez constitucional alemán (sobre la sentencia del Zweiter...
  • “Special Issue – The OMT Decision of the German Federal Constitutional Court”, German Law Journal, vol. 15, núm. 2, 2014, pp. 107-382.
  • KUMM, M., “Rebel without a Good Cause: Karlsruhe’s Misguided Attempt to Draw the CJEU into a Game of Chicken and What the CJEU Might Do about...
  • THIELE, A., “Friendly or Unfriendly Act: The Historical Referral of the Constitutional Court to the ECJ Regarding the ECB’s OMT Program”,...
  • PLIAKOS, A. y ANAGNOSTARAS, G., “Blind Date Between Familiar Strangers: The German Constitutional Court Goes Luxembourg!”, German Law Journal,...
  • CRAIG, P. y MARKAKIS, M., “Gauweiler and the Legality of Outright Monetary Transactions”, European Law Review, vol. 41, núm. 1, 201, pp. 4-24.
  • MARTÍN RODRÍGUEZ, P., “A Missing Piece of European Emergency Law: Legal Certainty and Individuals’ Expectations in the EU Response to the...
  • PLIAKOS, A. y ANAGNOSTARAS, G., “Saving Face? The German Federal Constitutional Court Decides Gauweiler”, German Law Journal, vol. 18, núm....
  • LÓPEZ CASTILLO, A., “Europaei, audi, quid convenit statuitque domina verbum! Una muestra (aún) reciente de la actual jurisprudencia ius europea...
  • FABBRINI, F., “After the OMT Case: The Supremacy of EU Law as the Guarantee of the Equality of the Member States”, German Law Journal, vol....
  • KELEMEN, D., “On the Unsustainability of Constitutional Pluralism”, Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law, vol. 23 2016, pp....
  • WILKINSON, M.A., “Constitutional pluralism: Chronicle of a death foretold?”, European Law Journal, vol. 23, 2017, pp. 213-233.
  • GOLDMANN, M., “Discretion, not Rules: Post-Unitary Constitutional Pluralism in the Economic and Monetary Union”, en G. Davies y M. Avbelj,...
  • PIERDOMINICI, L., “The Theory of EU Constitutional Pluralism: A Crisis in a Crisis?”, Perspectives on Federalism, vol. 9, núm. 2, 2017, pp....
  • HERNÁNDEZ DE COS, P., “La política monetaria del Banco Central Europeo durante la crisis y los retos de futuro”, Información Comercial Española,...
  • LÓPEZ CASTILLO, A., “Cuestión prejudicial en segunda ronda. Una nueva escaramuza a propósito de la política monetaria del BCE”, Revista General...
  • BOBIĆ, A. y DAWSON, M., “Quantitative Easing at the Court of Justice – Doing whatever it takes to save the euro: Weiss and Others”, Common...
  • MOOIJ, A.A.M., “The Weiss judgment: The Court’s further clarification of the ECB’s legal framework: Case C-493/17 Weiss and others, EU:C:2018:1000”,...
  • MARTÍN RODRÍGUEZ, P., “The principle of legal certainty and the limits to the applicability of EU law”, Cahiers de droit européen, vol. 50,...
  • GRIMM, D., WENDEL, M. Y REINBACHER, T., “European Constitutionalism and the German Basic Law”, en A. Albi and S. Bardutzky (eds.), National...
  • PERJU, V., “Against Bidimensional Supremacy in EU Constitutionalism”, German Law Journal, vol. 21, núm. 5, 2020, p. 1021, doi:10.1017/glj.2020.59.
  • AZPITARTE SÁNCHEZ, M., “Integración europea y legitimidad de la jurisdicción constitucional”, Revista de Derecho Comunitario Europeo, núm....
  • BAQUERO CRUZ, J., “The Legacy of the Maastricht-Urteil and the Pluralist Movement”, European Law Journal, vol. 14, núm. 4, 2008, pp. 389-422.
  • BAQUERO CRUZ, J., “Another Look at Constitutional Pluralism in the European Union”, European Law Journal, vol. 22, 2016, pp. 356-374.
  • FABBRINI, F. y SAJÓ, A., “The dangers of constitutional identity”, European Law Journal, vol. 25, 2019, pp. 456-473.
  • MAYER, F., “To Boldly Go Where No Court Has Gone Before. The German Federal Constitutional Court’s ultra vires Decision of May 5, 2020”, German...
  • PETERSEN, N., “Karlsruhe’s Lochner Moment? A Rational Choice Perspective on the German Federal Constitutional Court’s Relationship to the...
  • SIMON, S. y RATHKE, H., loc. cit., p. 954. Contra, SCHNEIDER, K., “Gauging “Ultra-Vires”: The Good Parts”, German Law Journal, vol. 21, núm....
  • DÍEZ-HOCHLEITNER, J.: “El Derecho a la última palabra: ¿Tribunales constitucionales o Tribunal de Justicia de la Unión?”, Working Paper on...
  • ZILLER, J., “General Report”, en Czuczai, P. Darák, P. Láncos, M Szabó y A. Varga (eds.), Division of Competences and Regulatory Powers between...
  • AVBELJ, M., “Constitutional Pluralism and Authoritarianism”, German Law Journal, vol. 21, núm. 5, 2020, pp. 1023-1031, doi:10.1017/glj.2020.56.
  • AVBELJ, M., The European Union under transnational law. A pluralist appraisal, Hart, Oxford, 2018.
  • ARROYO JIMÉNEZ, L., “Constitutional Empathy and Judicial Dialogue in the European Union”, European Public Law, vol. 24, núm. 1, 2018, pp....
  • MARTÍN RODRÍGUEZ, P., “Dialogical rule of law y respuesta europea a la crisis“ , en HINOJOSA MARTÍNEZ, L. M.; MARTÍN RODRÍGUEZ, P.(dirs.),...
  • GALETTA, D.-U., “Karlsruhe über alles? The reasoning on the principle of proportionality in the judgment of 5 May 2020 of the German BVerfG...
  • GALETTA, D.-U., “Il principio di proporzionalità fra diritto nazionale e diritto europeo (e con uno sguardo anche al di là dei confini dell’Unione...
  • TUORI, K., “The ECB’s quantitative easing programme as a constitutional game changer“, Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law,...
  • MARTÍN RODRÍGUEZ, P., “National Report. Spain”, en Czuczai, P. Darák, P. Láncos, M Szabó y A. Varga (eds.), Division of Competences and Regulatory...
  • LÓPEZ ESCUDERO, M., “La nueva gobernanza económica de la UE: ¿una auténtica Unión Económica en formación?”, Revista de Derecho Comunitario...
  • FROMAGE, D., “Guaranteeing the ECB’s democratic accountability in the post-Banking Union era: An ever more difficult task?”, Maastricht Journal...
  • AMTENBRINK, F, “The European Central Bank’s intricate independence versus accountability conundrum in the post-crisis governance framework”,...
  • PETERSEN, N., “Alexy and the “German” Model of Proportionality: Why the Theory of Constitutional Rights Does Not Provide a Representative...
  • ÖBERG, J., ”The German Federal Constitutional Court’s PSPP Judgment: Proportionality Review Par Excellence”, blog [European law blog], 2/6/2020.
  • MARTUCCI, F., ”La BCE et la Cour constitutionnelle allemande : souligner les paradoxes de l’arrêt du 5 mai de la Cour constitutionnelle allemande”,...
  • Editorial Comment: “Europe and its multiple Constitutions”, blog [EU Law Live], 15/7/2020.
  • UTRILLA, D., “Three months after Weiss: Was nun?”, blog [EU Law Live], 5/8/2020.
  • BURCHARDT, D. “Backlash against the Court of Justice of the EU? The Recent Jurisprudence of the German Constitutional Court on EU Fundamental...
  • THYM, D., “Friendly Takeover, or: the Power of the ‘First Word’. The German Constitutional Court Embraces the Charter of Fundamental Rights...
  • MADSEN, M., CEBULAK, P., y WIEBUSCH, M., “Backlash against international courts: Explaining the forms and patterns of resistance to international...
  • MADER, O., “Enforcement of EU Values as a Political Endeavour: Constitutional Pluralism and Value Homogeneity in Times of Persistent Challenges...
  • MARTÍN RODRÍGUEZ, P., “Estado de derecho y sistema jurídico de la Unión”, en LIÑÁN NOGUERAS, D. J.; MARTÍN RODRÍGUEZ, P. J. (dirs.): Estado...