The Role of Doctrinal Writing in Creating Administrative Law: France and England Compared

• Autores: John Bell
• Localización: Glossae: European Journal of Legal History, ISSN-e 2255-2707, ISSN 0214-669X, Nº 15, 2018, págs. 140-154
• Idioma: inglés
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo (pdf)
• Resumen

  • The paper is about the place of doctrinal legal writing in the formation of administrative law. The paper examines the conditions which appear to be necessary in order to bring into existence a distinct new branch of law: a body of distinctive rules, a distinctive court or procedure by which the body of law is adjudicated, programmes of teaching in which the subject is handed down to students and professionals in a coherent manner, and a body of writers who interact with each other and produce works which systematise the law.

    While the focus is on English and French administrative law, the implications are not limited to those jurisdictions.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Anderson, S., The Oxford History of the Laws of England, Oxford, 2010, vol. XI, Part II, Ch. VI
  • Bell, J., “Researching Globalization: Lessons from Judicial Citations”, Cambridge Journal of International and Comparative Law 3(3) (2014),...
  • Birkinshaw, P., Harden. I., and Lewis, N., Government by Moonlight: The Hybrid Parts of the State, London, 1990.
  • Borchard, E.M., Declaratory Judgments, 2nd edn., Cleveland, 1941.
  • Brissaud, J., A History of French Public Law, London, 1915.
  • Cocks, R., and Cownie, F., ‘A Great and Noble Occupation!’, A History if the Society of Legal Scholars, Oxford, 2009.
  • Committee on Ministers’ Powers, Cmd. 4060, London, 1932.
  • Craig, P.P., Public law and democracy in the United Kingdom and the United States of America, Oxford, 1990.
  • Davis, K.C., Administrative Law, St Paul, Minn., 1951.
  • De Smith, S.A., Judicial Review of Administrative Action, London, 1959.
  • Dicey, A.V., Lectures on Comparative Constitutionalism (J. Allison, ed.), Oxford, 2013.
  • Duguit, L.: “French Administrative Courts”, Political Science Quarterly (1914), 390.
  • Duguit, L.: Law in the Modern State (trans. Laski F. and H.), London, 1921.
  • Ernst, W. (ed.), The Development of Traffic Liability, Cambridge, 2014.
  • Fortsakis, T., Conceptualisme et empiricisme en droit administratif français, Paris, 1987.
  • Friedmann, W., The allied military government of Germany, London, 1947.
  • Garner, J.F., and Brown, L.N., (with the help of Questiaux, N.), French Administrative Law, 1st edn., London, 1967.
  • Gellhorn, W., Administrative Law: Case and Comments, Brooklyn, 1947.
  • Gelter, M., and Siems, M. “Citations to Foreign Courts – Illegitimate and Superfluous, or Unavoidable? Evidence from Europe'”, American...
  • Gonod, P.: Édouard Laferrière, un Juriste au Service de la République, Paris, 1997.
  • Gonod, P.: “Les membres du Conseil d’État, auteurs de manuels de droit administratif”, Le Conseil d’État et l’Université (J. Caillosse, ed.),...
  • Goodnow, F.J., Comparative Administrative Law: an analysis of the administrative systems, national and local, of the United States, England,...
  • Gordon, D.M., “The Relation of Facts to Jurisdiction”, Law Quarterly Review 45 (1929), 459.
  • Griffith, J.A.G., and Street, H., Principles of Administrative Law, London, 1952.
  • Hakim, N., L’autorité de la doctrine civiliste française au XIXe siècle, Paris , 2002.
  • Hamson, J., Executive Discretion and Judicial Control. An Aspect of the French Conseil d’Etat, London, 1954.
  • Harden, I., and Lewis, N., The Noble Lie: the British Constitution and the Rule of Law, London, 1986.
  • Hart, W.O., and Beattie, D.J., Hart’s introduction to the law of local government and administration, 3rd edn, London, 1946.
  • Jenks, E., “English Legal Education”, Law Quarterly Review 51 (1935), 162.
  • Jennings, W.I.:“Courts and Administrative Law” (1936) 49 Harvard Law Review, 426.
  • Jennings, W.I., Robson, W.A., and Wade, E.C.S., “Administrative Law and the Teaching of Public Law”, Journal of the Society of Public Teachers...
  • Jestaz, P., and Jamin, C., La Doctrine, Paris, 2004.
  • Law Commission, Remedies in Administrative Law, Law Com., No. 73, Cmnd. 6407, 1976.
  • MacCormick, D.N., Legal Reasoning and Legal Theory, Oxford, 1978.
  • Mestre, A., “Droit administratif”, Cambridge Law Journal 3 (1929), 355.
  • Mestre, J-L.: Introduction historique au droit administratif français, Paris, 1985.
  • Mestre, J-L.: “Aux origines de l’enseignement du droit administratif: le Cours de législation administrative de Portiez de l’Oise (1808)”,...
  • Mitchell, J.D.B., “The State of Public Law in the U.K.”, International and Comparative Law Quarterly 15 (1966), 133.
  • Mitchell, P., “Legal Change”, Current Legal Problems (2012), 177.
  • Port, F.J., Administrative Law, London, 1929.
  • Report of the Committee on Ministers Powers, Cmd. 4060, London, 1932.
  • Report of the Committee on Administrative Tribunals and Enquiries, Cmnd. 218, 1957.
  • Robson, W.A., Justice and Administrative Law. A Study of the British Constitution, 1st edn., London, 1928.
  • Schwartz, B.: Law and the Executive in Britain, New York, 1949.
  • Schwartz, B.: French Administrative Law and the Common Law World, New York, 1954.
  • Simpson, R., The Development of the PhD Degree in Britain, 1917-1959, and Since, Lewiston NY, 2009.
  • Stebbings, C., Legal Foundations of Tribunals in Nineteenth Century England, Cambridge, 2006.
  • Stirn, B., “Les commissaires du gouvernement et la doctrine”, La Revue Administrative 1997 numéro spécial : Le Conseil d’État et la Doctrine.
  • Street, H., “Law and Administration: Implications for University Education”, Political Studies (1953).
  • Touziel-Divina, M., La doctrine publiciste 1800-1880, Paris, 2009.
  • Stein, L. von, Handbuch der Verwaltungslehre und des Verwaltungsrechts mit Vergleichung der Literatur und Gesetzgebung von Frankreich, England...
  • Wade, H.W.R.: Administrative Law, 1st edn., Oxford, 1961.
  • Wade, H.W.R.: Towards Administrative Justice, Ann Arbor, 1963
  • Wade, H.W.R., and C.F.Forsyth, C.F., Administrative Law, 11th edn., Oxford, 2014.
  • Whittaker, S. (ed.), The Development of Product Liability, Cambridge, 2014.
  • Williams, G.L., Crown Proceedings, London, 1948.
  • Wilson, J.F., “A Survey of Legal Education in the United Kingdom”, JSPTL (NS) 9 (1966) 1, 46.