Are Fish Consumption Advisories for the Great Lakes Adequately Protective against Chemical Mixtures?

• Nilima Gandhi ^[1] ; Ken G. Drouillard ^[2] ; George B. Arhonditsis ^[1] ; Sarah B. Gewurtz ^[2] ; Satyendra P. Bhavsar ^[1]
  1. [1] University of Toronto

     University of Toronto

     Canadá

     
  2. [2] University of Windsor

     University of Windsor

     Canadá

     
• Localización: Environmental health perspectives, ISSN 0091-6765, Vol. 125, Nº. 4, 2017, págs. 586-593
• Idioma: inglés
• DOI: 10.1289/EHP104
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo
• Resumen

  • The North American Great Lakes are home to > 140 types of fish and are famous for recreational and commercial fishing. However, the presence of toxic substances has resulted in the issuance of fish consumption advisories that are typically based on the most restrictive contaminant.

    We investigated whether these advisories, which typically neglect the existence of a mixture of chemicals and their possible additive adverse effects, are adequately protective of the health of humans consuming fish from the Canadian waters of the Great Lakes.

    Using recent fish contaminant monitoring data collected by the government of Ontario, Canada, we simulated advisories using most-restrictive-contaminant (one-chem) and multi-contaminant additive effect (multi-chem) approaches. The advisories from the two simulations were compared to determine if there is any deficiency in the currently issued advisories.

    Approximately half of the advisories currently issued are potentially not adequately protective. Of the four Great Lakes studied, the highest percentage of advisories affected are in Lake Ontario if an additive effect is considered. Many fish that are popular for consumption, such as walleye, salmon, bass and trout, would have noticeably more stringent advisories.

    Improvements in the advisories may be needed to ensure that the health of humans consuming fish from the Great Lakes is protected. In this region, total polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and mercury are the major contaminants causing restrictions on consuming fish, whereas dioxins/furans, toxaphene, and mirex/photomirex are of minor concern. Regular monitoring of most organochlorine pesticides and metals in fish can be discontinued.

    Gandhi N, Drouillard KG, Arhonditsis GB, Gewurtz SB, Bhavsar SP. 2017. Are fish consumption advisories for the Great Lakes adequately protective against chemical mixtures? Environ Health Perspect 125:586–593; http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/EHP104

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • (2006). Ontario Ministry of the Environment. Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
  • Bemis, JC, Seegal, RF. (1999). Polychlorinated biphenyls and methylmercury act synergistically to reduce rat brain dopamine content. Environ...
  • Bhavsar, SP, Awad, E, Fletcher, R, Hayton, A, Somers, KM, Kolic, T. (2008). Temporal trends and spatial distribution of dioxins and furans...
  • Bhavsar, SP, Awad, E, Mahon, CG, Petro, S. (2011). Great Lakes fish consumption advisories: is mercury a concern?. Ecotoxicology. 20. 1588-1598
  • Bhavsar, SP, Fletcher, R, Hayton, A, Reiner, EJ, Jackson, DA. (2007). Composition of dioxin-like PCBs in fish: an application for risk assessment.....
  • Bhavsar, SP, Gewurtz, SB, McGoldrick, DJ, Keir, MJ, Backus, SM. (2010). Changes in mercury levels in Great Lakes fish between 1970s and 2007.....
  • Bhavsar, SP, Hayton, A, Reiner, EJ, Jackson, DA. (2007). Estimating dioxin-like polychlorinated biphenyl toxic equivalents from total polychlorinated...
  • Bhavsar, SP, Jackson, DA, Hayton, A, Reiner, EJ, Chen, T, Bodnar, J. (2007). Are PCB levels in fish from the Canadian Great Lakes still declining?....
  • Bhavsar, SP, Reiner, EJ, Hayton, A, Fletcher, R, MacPherson, K. (2008). Converting Toxic Equivalents (TEQ) of dioxins and dioxin-like compounds...
  • (2000). Royal Ontario Museum. Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
  • (2001). EAGLE Eating Patterns Survey..
  • Fischer, C, Fredriksson, A, Eriksson, P. (2008). Neonatal co-exposure to low doses of an ortho-PCB (PCB 153) and methyl mercury exacerbate...
  • (2012). Fisheries and Oceans Canada. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
  • Gandhi, N, Bhavsar, SP, Tang, RWK, Drouillard, KG, Arhonditsis, GB. (2014). Significance of toxaphene in Great Lakes fish consumption advisories.....
  • Gandhi, N, Tang, RWK, Bhavsar, SP, Reiner, EJ, Morse, D, Arhonditsis, GB. (2015). Is mirex still a contaminant of concern for the North American...
  • Gewurtz, SB, Backus, SM, Bhavsar, SP, McGoldrick, DJ, de Solla, SR, Murphy, EW. (2011). Contaminant biomonitoring programs in the Great Lakes...
  • Gewurtz, SB, Bhavsar, SP, Fletcher, R. (2011). Influence of fish size and sex on mercury/PCB concentration: importance for fish consumption...
  • (1993). Great Lakes Sport Fish Advisory Task Force. Chicago, IL.
  • (2006). The metal uptake and accumulation in fish living in polluted waters. In:. Springer,107–114. New York.
  • Mozaffarian, D, Rimm, E. (2006). Fish intake, contaminants, and human health: evaluating the risks and the benefits.. JAMA. 295. 1885-1899
  • (2012). Contaminants in Great Lakes fish: historic, current, and emerging concerns. In:. Michigan State University Press. East Lansing, MI.
  • Neff, MR, Bhavsar, SP, Ni, FJ, Carpenter, DO, Drouillard, K, Fisk, AT. (2014). Risk-benefit of consuming Lake Erie fish.. Environ Res. 134....
  • Neff, MR, Robinson, JM, Bhavsar, SP. (2013). Assessment of fish mercury levels in the upper St. Lawrence River, Canada.. J Great Lakes Res....
  • (2015). About Our Lakes: Economy..
  • (2015). OMOECC. Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
  • Piedrafita, B, Erceg, S, Cauli, O, Felipo, V. (2008). Developmental exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls or methylmercury, but not to its...
  • Roegge, CS, Wang, VC, Powers, BE, Klintsova, AY, Villareal, S, Greenough, WT. (2004). Motor impairment in rats exposed to PCBs and methylmercury...
  • Sadraddini, S, Azim, ME, Shimoda, Y, Mahmood, M, Bhavsar, SP, Backus, SM. (2011). Temporal PCB and mercury trends in Lake Erie fish communities:...
  • Sherer, RA, Price, PS. (1993). The effect of cooking processes on PCB levels in edible fish tissue.. Qual Assur. 2. 396-407
  • (2014). Michigan Department of Community Health. Lansing, MI.
  • (1986). U.S.EPA. Washington, DC.
  • (2000). U.S. EPA. Washington, DC.
  • (2015). Choose Fish and Shellfish Wisely: Fish and Shellfish Advisories and Safe Eating Guidelines..
  • Visha, A, Gandhi, N, Bhavsar, SP, Arhonditsis, GB. (2016). Guiding fish consumption advisories for Lake Ontario: a Bayesian hierarchical approach.....