Una revisión crítica de la toma de decisiones multi-criterio en áreas protegidas

• Mónica de Castro Pardo ^[1] ; Vicente Urios ^[2]
  1. [1] Universidad Rey Juan Carlos

     Universidad Rey Juan Carlos

     Madrid, España

     
  2. [2] Universitat d'Alacant

     Universitat d'Alacant

     Alicante, España

     
• Localización: Economía agraria y recursos naturales, ISSN-e 2174-7350, ISSN 1578-0732, Vol. 16, Nº. 2, 2016, págs. 89-109
• Idioma: español
• DOI: 10.7201/earn.2016.02.04
• Títulos paralelos:
  • A critical review of multi-criteria decision making in protected areas
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo (pdf)
• Dialnet Métricas: 1 Cita
• Resumen
  • español

    El análisis multi-criterio para toma de decisiones colaborativa ofrece una herramienta útil para mejorar la gobernanza en áreas protegidas, con fuertes conflictos de intereses entre agentes. Este artículo ofrece una revisión en profundidad sobre métodos MCDM en áreas protegidas. El análisis considera los temas Uso de la tierra, Gestión, Especies y Zonificación, y se basa en dos dimensiones: Métodos y Participación. Los Temas y las Técnicas MCDM y los Temas y la Participación están significativamente correlacionados respectivamente según un test Chi-cuadrado. Hemos identificado dos grupos: Especies y Zonificación usan métodos continuos no participativos y Uso de la tierra y Gestión, utilizan métodos discretos donde la participación es creciente.

  • English

    Multi-criteria analysis in collaborative decision making can provide a useful tool to improve the governance in protected areas with strong conflicts between stakeholders. This paper offers an in-depth review about MCDM methods in protected areas. The analysis considers the topics Land Use, Management, Species, and Zoning and it is based in two dimensions: Methods and Participation. Topics and MCDM methods and Topics and Participation were significantly related and contrasted using a Chi-squared test, respectively. We have identified two groups by topics: Zoning and Species use continuous non participative methods and Land Use and Management use discrete methods with increasing participation

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Ananda, J. (2007). "Implementing participatory decision making in forest planning". Environmental Management, 39(4): 534-544. http://doi.org/bdrq4n.
  • Ananda, J. and Herath, G. (2008). "Multi-attribute preference modelling and regional land-use planning". Ecological Economics, 65(2):...
  • Ananda, J. and Herath, G. (2009). "A critical review of multi-criteria decision making methods with special reference to forest management...
  • Ananda, J. and Proctor, W. (2013). "Collaborative approaches to water management and planning: An institutional perspective". Ecological...
  • Arabatzis, G. and Grigoroudis, E. (2010). "Visitors' satisfaction, perceptions and gap analysis: The case of Dadia-Lefkimi-Souflion...
  • Arciniegas, G., Janssen, R. and Omtzigt, N. (2011). "Map-based multicriteria analysis to support interactive land use allocation"....
  • Belton, V. and Stewart, T. (2002). Multiple criteria decision analysis: an integrated approach. Springer Science and Business Media.
  • Bertomeu, M. and Romero, C. (2001). "Managing forest biodiversity: a zero-one goal programming approach". Agricultural Systems, 68:...
  • Bojórquez-Tapia, L.A., de la Cueva, H., Diaz, S., Melgarejo, D., Alcantar, G., Solares, M.J. and Cruz-Bello, G. (2004). "Environmental...
  • Davis, F.W., Costello, C. and Stoms, D. (2006). "Efficient conservation in a utility-maximization framework". Ecology and Society,...
  • Dearden, P., Bennett, M. and Johnston, J. (2005). "Trends in global protected area governance, 1992-2002". Environmental Management,...
  • Dhar, A., Ruprecht, H. and Vacik, H. (2008). "Population viability risk management (PVRM) for in situ management of endangered tree species....
  • Diaz-Balteiro, L. and Romero, C. (2008). "Making forestry decisions with multiple criteria: A review and an assessment". Forest Ecology...
  • Duke, J.M. and Aull-Hyde, R. (2002). "Identifying public preferences for land preservation using the analytic hierarchy process"....
  • Estévez, R.A. and Gelcich, S. (2015). "Participative multi-criteria decision analysis in marine management and conservation: Research...
  • Greco, S., Figueira, J. and Ehrgott, M. (2005). Multiple criteria decision analysis. Springer's International series. Springer, New York.
  • Fitzsimons, J., Pearson, C.J., Lawson, C. and Hill, M.J. (2012). "Evaluation of land- use planning in greenbelts based on intrinsic characteristics...
  • Fuller, D.O., Meijaard, E.M., Christy, L. and Jessup, T.C. (2010). "Spatial assessment of threats to biodiversity within East Kalimantan,...
  • Gómez-Navarro, T., García-Melón, M. and Acuna-Dutra, S. (2010). "An ANP approach to assess the sustainability of tourist strategies for...
  • Graham, J., Amos, B. and Plumptre, T.W. (2003). Governance principles for protected areas in the 21st century. Proceeedings from the Fifth...
  • Hajkowicz, S.A. (2008). "Supporting multi-stakeholder environmental decisions". Journal of Environmental Management, 88(4): 607-614....
  • Hajkowicz, S. (2009). "Cutting the cake: Supporting environmental fund allocation decisions". Journal of Environmental Management,...
  • Herath, G. (2004). "Incorporating community objectives in improved wetland management: The use of the analytic hierarchy process"....
  • Hiltunen, V., Kurttila, M., Leskinen, P., Pasanen, K. and Pykäläinen, J. (2009). "Mesta: An internet-based decision-support application...
  • Hjortso, C.N. (2004). "Enhancing public participation in natural resource management using Soft OR-an application of strategic option...
  • Huang, I.B., Keisler, J. and Linkov, I. (2011). "Multi-criteria decision analysis in environmental sciences: Ten years of applications...
  • Kazana, V., Fawcett, R.H. and Mutch, W.E. (2003). "A decision support modelling framework for multiple use forest management: The Queen...
  • Kijazi, M.H. and Kant, S. (2011). "Social acceptability of alternative forest regimes in Mount Kilimanjaro, Tanzania, using stakeholder...
  • Kiker, G.A., Bridges, T.S., Varghese, A., Seager, T.P. and Linkov, I. (2005). "Application of multicriteria decision analysis in environmental...
  • Kurttila, M., Pukkala, T. and Loikkanen, J. (2002). "The performance of alternative spatial objective types in forest planning calculations:...
  • Kurttila, M., Pykäläinen, J. and Leskinen, P. (2006). "Defining the forest landowner's utility-loss compensative subsidy level for...
  • Liu, X., Lao, C., Li, X., Liu, Y. and Chen, Y. (2012). "An integrated approach of remote sensing, GIS and swarm intelligence for zoning...
  • Lu, S.Y., Shen, C.H. and Chiau, W.Y. (2014). "Zoning strategies for marine protected areas in Taiwan: Case study of Gueishan Island in...
  • Marttunen, M. and Hämäläinen, R.P. (2008). "The decision analysis interview approach in the collaborative management of a large regulated...
  • Mendoza, G.A. and Prabhu, R. (2000). "Development of a methodology for selecting criteria and indicators of sustainable forest management:...
  • Mendoza, G.A. and Martins, H. (2006). "Multi-criteria decision analysis in natural resource management: a critical review of methods and...
  • Moffett, A. and Sarkar, S. (2006). "Incorporating multiple criteria into the design of conservation area networks: a minireview with recommendations"....
  • Moilanen, A. (2007). "Landscape zonation, benefit functions and target-based planning: Unifying reserve selection strategies". Biological...
  • Moilanen, A. and Arponen, A. (2011). "Setting conservation targets under budgetary constraints". Biological Conservation, 144(1):...
  • Mustajoki, J., Saarikoski, H., Marttunen, M., Ahtikoski, A., Hallikainen, V., Helle, T. and Varmola, M. (2011). "Use of decision analysis...
  • Nordström, E.M., Eriksson, L.O. and Öhman, K. (2010). "Integrating multiple criteria decision analysis in participatory forest planning:...
  • Oikonomou, V., Dimitrakopoulos, P.G. and Troumbis, A.Y. (2011). "Incorporating ecosystem function concept in environmental planning and...
  • Ostrom, E. (2000). "Collective action and the evolution of social norms". Journal of Natural Resources Policy Research, 6(4): 235-252....
  • Pasqualini, V., Oberti, P., Vigetta, S., Riffard, O., Panaïotis, C., Cannac, M. and Ferrat, L. (2011). "A GIS-based multicriteria evaluation...
  • Pavlikakis, G.E. and Tsihrintzis, V.A. (2003). "Integrating humans in ecosystem management using multi-criteria decision making"....
  • Prato, T. (1999). "Multiple attribute decision analysis for ecosystem management". Ecological Economics, 30(2): 207-222. http://doi.org/cx28nt.
  • Prato, T. (2000). "Multiple attribute evaluation of landscape management". Journal of Environmental Management, 60(4): 325-337. http://doi.org/dr6b3w.
  • Proctor, W. and Drechsler, M. (2003). "Deliberative multi-criteria evaluation: a case study of recreation and tourism options in Victoria,...
  • Proctor, W. and Qureshi, E. (2005). "Multi-criteria evaluation revisited". In Proceedings of the Australia New Zealand Society for...
  • Reza, M.I.H., Abdullah, S.A., Nor, S.B.M. and Ismail, M.H. (2013). "Integrating GIS and expert judgment in a multi-criteria analysis to...
  • Riccioli, F., Fratini, R., Boncinelli, F., El Asmar, T., El Asmar, J.P. and Casini, L. (2016). "Spatial analysis of selected biodiversity...
  • Romero-Calcerrada, R. and Luque, S. (2006). "Habitat quality assessment using weights-of-evidence based GIS modelling: The case of Picoides...
  • Rudolphi, W. and Haider, W. (2003). "Visitor management and ecological integrity: one example of an integrated management approach using...
  • Schmoldt, D.L. and Peterson, D.L. (2001). "Strategic and tactical planning for managing national park resources". In Schmoldt, D.,...
  • Sharifi, M.A., Van den Toorn, W., Rico, A. and Emmanuel, M. (2002). "Application of GIS and multicriteria evaluation in locating sustainable...
  • Store, R. and Kangas, J. (2001). "Integrating spatial multi-criteria evaluation and expert knowledge for GIS-based habitat suitability...
  • Strager, M.P. and Rosenberger, R.S. (2006). "Incorporating stakeholder preferences for land conservation: Weights and measures in spatial...
  • Terra, T.N., dos Santos, R.F. and Costa, D.C. (2014). "Land use changes in protected areas and their future: The legal effectiveness of...
  • Tzionas, P., Ioannidou, I.A. and Paraskevopoulos, S. (2004). "A hierarchical fuzzy decision support system for the environmental rehabilitation...
  • United Nations Development Programme. (1999). Human development report 1999. Oxford University Press, New York.
  • Vacik, H., Kurttila, M., Hujala, T., Khadka, C., Haara, A., Pykäläinen, J., Honkakoski, P., Wolfslhener, B. and Tikkanen, J. (2014). "Evaluating...
  • Vimal, R., Pluvinet, P., Sacca, C., Mazagol, P.O., Etlicher, B. and Thompson, J.D. (2012). "Exploring spatial patterns of vulnerability...
  • Walter, M., Tomas, S.L., Munda, G. and Larrea, C. (2016). "A social multi-criteria evaluation approach to assess extractive and non-extractive...
  • Wolfslehner, B. and Vacik, H. (2008). "Evaluating sustainable forest management strategies with the analytic network process in a pressure-state-response...
  • Wood, L.J. and Dragicevic, S. (2007). "GIS-based multicriteria evaluation and fuzzy sets to identify priority sites for marine protection"....
  • Yilmaz, B. and Harmancioglu, N.B. (2010). "Multi-criteria decision making for water resource management: A case study of the Gediz River...
  • Young, J.A., van Manen, F.T. and Thatcher, C.A. (2011). "Geographic profiling to assess the risk of rare plant poaching in natural areas"....
  • Zendehdel, K., Rademaker, M., De Baets, B. and Van Huylenbroeck, G. (2010). "Environmental decision making with conflicting social groups:...
  • Zhang, Z., Sherman, R., Yang, Z., Wu, R., Wang, W., Yin, M., Yang, G. and Ou, X. (2013). "Integrating a participatory process with a GIS-based...