At least seven years had passed since subject librarians at Santa Clara University Library performed a comprehensive review of their information resources. A review including journal subscriptions, institutional changes (including a new Cataloging and Metadata Librarian and University Librarian), as well as a new strategic plan, contributed to high noon being declared. Roping together duty and determination, subject librarians, technical services staff, and EBSCO representatives worked together to tame the Wild West landscape and bring order to the new frontier.