Negocia o atente a las consecuencias: La condena en costas en los derechos del Common Law y su aplicación en el proceso civil español

• Autores: Pablo Cortés, Francisco Sotelo
• Localización: Indret: Revista para el Análisis del Derecho, ISSN-e 1698-739X, Nº. 4, 2011, 37 págs.
• Idioma: español
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo
• Dialnet Métricas: 4 Citas
• Resumen

  • La adjudicación de conflictos civiles es cara y lenta; además, la mayoría de los tribunales están sobrecargados de casos pendientes. Con el objetivo de acelerar la resolución de pleitos las jurisdicciones del common law promueven el acuerdo entre las partes. El presente trabajo analiza el concepto de las propuestas de acuerdo que se llevan a cabo en Inglaterra, Irlanda y los Estados Unidos. Las propuestas de acuerdo son ofertas confidenciales que pueden hacer uno de los litigantes al otro en los tribunales de tradición anglosajona. Estos acuerdos tienen consecuencias automáticas de condena en costas. El presente trabajo indaga sobre los motivos por los cuales dicha figura procesal �de gran éxito� no ha sido implementada en los países de tradición jurídica romana, en particular dentro del derecho procesal en España.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Poupak ANJOMSHOAA (2007), “Cost Awards in International Arbitration and the Use of ‘Sealed Offers’ to Limit Liability for Costs”, International...
  • ASSOCIATION OF BRITISH INSURERS (2009), “Analysis of Personal Injury Legal Costs”, Research Brief, MDU Journal, January 2009.
  • S. ATHERTON (2007), “Dispute Resolution: Part 36 Offers–New Provisions”, LNTV times, Programme 1292.
  • Smith BAILEY et al. (2007), The Modern English Legal System, 5ª ed., Thomson, Londres, pp. 647-667.
  • Matthew BRUNSDON-TULLY (2009), “There is an A in ADR but Does Anyone Know What it Means Anymore?”, Civil Justice Quarterly, Vol. 28, núm....
  • Francisco CABRILLO y Sean FITZPATRICK (2008), The Economics of Litigation, Edward-Elgar, Northampton (Reino Unido), pp. 121-130.
  • Fabrizio CAFAGGI y Hans MICKLITZ (2009), New Frontiers of Consumer Protection: The Interplay between Private and Public Enforcement, Intersentia,...
  • Oscar CHASE et al. (2007), Civil Litigation in Comparative Context, Thomson West, Estados Unidos.
  • Michael COOK (2011), Cook on Costs, Butterworths Lexis Nexis, Edimburgo (Reino Unido).
  • Pablo CORTÉS (2009), “An Analysis of Offers to Settle in Common Law Courts: Are They Relevant in the Civil Law Context?”, Electronic Journal...
  • Donald COURSEY y Linda STANLEY (1988), “Pretrial Bargaining Behaviour within the Shadow of the Law: Theory and Experimental Evidence”, International...
  • Yves DERAINS y Eric SCHWARTZ (2005), A Guide to the ICC Rules of Arbitration, 2ª ed., Kluwer Arbitration.
  • Katy DOWELL (2008), “Jackson LJ drafted in to investigate litigation costs 10 years after Woolf”, The Lawyer, 11.10.2008.
  • Déirdre DWYER (2009), The Civil Procedure Rules Ten Years On, Oxford University Press.
  • W. EMOS y Nuno GAROUPA (2006), “US-Style Contingent Fees and UK-Style Conditional Fees: Agency Problems and Supply of Legal Services”, Managerial...
  • Fernando ESTEBAN DE LA ROSA y Guillermo OROZCO PARDO (Eds.) et al. (2010), Mediación y Arbitraje de Consumo, una Perspectiva Española, Europea...
  • Owen FISS (1984), “Against Settlement”, Yale Law Review, Vol. 93, pp.1076 y ss.
  • Hazel GENN (2010), The Hamlyn Lectures 2008: Judging Civil Justice, Cambridge University Press.
  • Brian GILL (2009), “Report of the Scottish Civil Courts Review, Final Report”, Scottish Civil Courts Review, Vol. 1 y 2, pp. 1 y ss.
  • Vicente GIMENO SENDRA (2007), Derecho Procesal Civil, I. El Proceso de Declaración, artículo General, 2ª ed., Colex, Madrid.
  • Cristopher HODGES, Stefan VOGENAUER, Magdalena TULIBACKA (2010), Costs and Funding of Civil Litigation, Oxford University Press.
  • Samuel ISSACHAROFF (2007), “Regulating after the Fact”, DePaul Law Review, Vol. 56, pp. 375 y ss.
  • Rupert JACKSON (2009), Review of Civil Litigation Costs: Preliminary Report, The Stationery Office, Norwich (Reino Unido).
  • Rupert JACKSON (2009), Review of Civil Litigation Costs: Final Report, The Stationery Office, Norwich (Reino Unido).
  • Jonh Anthony JOLOWICZ (2008), “Civil Litigation: What’s it for”, Cambridge Journal, Vol. 67, núm. 3, pp. 508-520.
  • Padraic LYONS (2005), “Recent Developments Relating to Lodgments and Tenders”, Journal of Civil Practice and Procedure, Vol. 1, pp. 6 y ss.
  • Brian MAIN y Andrew PARK (2002), “The Impact of Defendant Offers into Court on Negotiation in the Shadow of the Law: Experimental Evidence”,...
  • MEDICAL DEFENSE UNION (2009), “Put An End to Excessive Legal Costs”, The MDU Journal, Vol. 25, núm.1, pp. 1 y ss.
  • Geoffrey MILLER (1998), “The Legal-Economic Analysis of Comparative Civil Procedure”, American Journal of Comparative Law, Vol. 45, pp. 905...
  • MINISTRY OF JUSTICE (2011), Reforming the Civil Litigation Funding and Costs in England and Wales, Response of Lord Justice Jackson’s Recommendations,...
  • J. PHILLIPS (2008), “Alternative Dispute Resolution: An English View-Point”, discurso del Presidente del Tribunal Supremo de Gran Bretaña,...
  • Mitchell POLINSKY (1998), “The Deterrant Effects of Settlements and Trials”, International Review of Law and Economics, Vol. 8, pp. 114 y...
  • John SORABJI (2009), “Costs: CPR Part 36 – When Success is not to Your Advantage – Carver v BAA Plc and Multiplex Construction (UK) Ltd v...
  • Kathryn SPIER (2007), “Litigation”, en Mitchell POLINSKY y Steven SHAVELL (2007), Handbook of Law and Economics, North Holland, Elsevier.
  • SPOUR (2006), Economic Foundations of law, Thompson, Massachusetts, Estados Unidos.
  • Harry WOOLF (1995), Access to Justice: Interim Report to the Lord Chancellor on the Civil Justice System in England and Wales, HMSO, Londres...
  • Harry WOOLF (1996), Access to Justice: Final Report to the Lord Chancellor on the civil justice system in England and Wales, HMSO, Londres...
  • Adrian ZUCKERMAN (2001), Civil Justice in Crisis: Comparative Perspectives of Civil Procedure, Great Britain, Oxford University Press.
  • Adrian ZUCKERMAN (2000), “The Second Great English Reform of Civil Justice, A Triumph of Hope over Experience”, Hibernian Law Journal, Vol....