Gobernanza, procesos participativos y conflictos en los Espacios Naturales Protegidos de la Comunidad Autónoma del País Vasco

• Autores: María Ángeles Díez López , Iker Etxano Gandariasbeitia, Eneko Garmendia Oleaga
• Localización: Ekonomiaz: Revista vasca de economía, ISSN 0213-3865, Nº. 74, 2010 (Ejemplar dedicado a: Gobernanza y competitividad territorial), págs. 178-199
• Idioma: español
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Dialnet Métricas: 1 Cita
• Resumen
  • español

    El objetivo del artículo es explorar la potencialidad de la Evaluación Multi-criterio Social como enfoque metodológico para evaluar Espacios Naturales Protegidos (ENP) e iniciar un proceso de discusión sobre la conveniencia de incorporar esta metodología para la gobernanza de la Red Natura 2000 de la Comunidad Autónoma de Euskadi. Del caso de estudio analizado se desprende que la inclusión de la población local en un proceso participativo dirigido a la planificación y manejo de los ENP contribuiría a reducir el número y calado de conflictos potenciales. Asimismo, facilitaría la gobernanza efectiva de los ENP, lo que parece un reto ineludible para que las áreas protegidas logren sus objetivos y funciones.

  • English

    The aim of this article is to explore the potentiality of Social Multi-criteria Evaluation as approach to assess Natural Protected Areas (NPAs). Jointly, opening the discussion about incorporating this methodological approach for the governance of Natura 2000 sites within the Basque Country is pursued. Derived from the case study is concluded that including local community in participative processes aimed to plan and manage NPAs would reduce both number and significance of potential conflicts. It would also contribute to an effective governance of NPAs, which is an unavoidable challenge in order to achieve protected areas� objectives and functions.

  • euskara

    Gizarte Ebaluazio Irizpideaniztunak naturagune babestuak ebaluatzeko ikuspuntu metodologiko gisa duen potentzialtasuna aztertzea da artikulu honen helburua, eta orobat metodologia hori Euskal Autonomia Erkidegoko Natura 2000 Sarearen gobernantzarako erabiltzearen egokitasunari buruz eztabaida-prozesu bat abiaraztea. Aztertutako kasutik ondorioztatzen da tokian tokiko herritarrak naturagune babestuak planifikatzeko eta gobernatzeko prozesu partehartzaile batean sartzeak balizko gatazken kopurua eta munta gutxitzen lagunduko lukeela. Era berean, naturagune babestuen gobernantza erraztuko luke, eta hori saihestu ezineko erronka da, gune babestuek beren helburuak eta egitekoak bete ditzaten.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • ABELSON, J. Y GAUVIN, F. (2006): «Assessing the impacts of public participation: Concepts, Evidence and. Policy Implications», Canadian Policy...
  • BANVILLE, C., LANDRY, M., MARTEL, J.M. Y BOULAIRE, C. (1998): «A stakeholder approach to MCDA», Systems Research and Behavioural Science,...
  • BERGSENG, E. Y VATN, A. (2009): «Why protection of biodiversity creates conflict Some evidence from the Nordic countries», Journal of Forest...
  • BLOOMFIELD, D., COLLINS, K.. FRY, C. Y MUNTON, R. (2001): «Deliberation and inclusion: vehicles for increasing trust in UK public governance?»,...
  • BOARD ON SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL (1999): Our Common Journey: A Transition Toward Sustainability, National Academy...
  • BRUGNACH, M., DEWULF, A., PAHL-WOSTL, C. Y TAILLIEU, T. (2008): «Toward a relational concept of uncertainty: about knowing too little, knowing...
  • BRUN, A. (2006): «Les objectifs, principes et éléments de débat», en Brun, A. y Lasserre, F. (dir.), Politiques de l’eau. Grands principes...
  • CADIÑANOS, J.A. Y LOZANO, P. (2006): «Valoración biogeográfica de los bosques de la Reserva de la Biosfera de Urdaibai (Vizcaya)», Actas del...
  • CADIÑANOS, J.A. Y MEAZA, G. (1998): Bases para una Biogeografía aplicada. Criterios y sistemas de valoración de la vegetación, 145 pp., Geoforma...
  • CIANI, A., BOGGIA, A. Y MARINOZZI, G. (1993): «Metodologie di valutazione di alternative di parchi: il caso del Parco del Nera», Genio Rurale,...
  • COMISIÓN EUROPEA (2001): European governance: A white paper. COM(2001) 428 final, Bruselas.
  • DE MARCHI, B., FUNTOWICZ, S.O., LO CASCIO, S. Y MUNDA, G. (2000): «Combining participative and institutional approaches with multicriteria...
  • DOUGIL, A.J., FRASER, E.D.G., HOLDEN, J., HUBACEK, K., PRELL, C., REED, M.S., STAGL, S. Y STRINGER, L.C. (2006): «Learning from doing participatory...
  • FIORINO, D. (1990): «Citizen participation and environmental risk: A survey of institutional mechanism», Science, Technology, & Human...
  • FOLKE, C., HAHN, T., OLSSON, P. Y NORBERG, J. (2005): «Adaptive governance of social-ecological system», Annual Review of Environmental and...
  • FUNTOWICZ, S.O., MARTÍNEZ-ALÍER, J., MUNDA, G. Y RAVETZ, J. (2002): «Multicriteria-based environmental policy», en Abaza, H. y Branzini, A....
  • FUNTOWICZ, S.O. Y RAVETZ, J. (1990): Uncertainty and Quality in Science for Policy, Kluwer, Dordrecht.
  • FUNTOWICZ, S.O. Y RAVETZ, J. 1994: «Emergent complex systems», Futures, 26: 568-582.
  • FUNTOWICZ, S.O. Y RAVETZ, J. 1999: «Post-Normal Science and insight now maturing», Futures, 31: 641-646.
  • GAMBOA, G. (2006): «Social multi-criteria evaluation of different development scenarios of the Aysen region, Chile», Ecological Economics,...
  • GAMBOA, G. Y MUNDA, G. (2007): «The problem of windfarm location: A social multi-criteria evaluation framework», Energy Policy, 35: 1564-1583.
  • GARMENDIA, E., GAMBOA, G., FRANCO, J., GARMENDIA, J., LIRIA, P. Y OLAZABAL, M. (2010): «Social multi-criteria evaluation as a decision support...
  • GARMENDIA, E. Y STAGL, S. (2010): «Public participation for sustainability and social learning: Concepts and lessons from three case studies...
  • GIAMPIETRO, M., MAYUMI, K. Y MUNDA, G. (2006): «Integrated assessment and energy analysis: Quality assurance in multi-criteria analysis of...
  • GUIMARÃES-PEREIRA, A., GUEDES, S. Y TOGNETTI, S. (2006): Interfaces Between Science and Society, Greenleaf Publishing, Sheffield.
  • HARREMOËS, P., GEE, D., MACGARVIN, M., STIRLING, A., KETS, J., WYNNE, B. Y GUEDES VAZ, S. (2001): Late lessons from early warnings: the precautionary...
  • HJORTSØ, C.N., STRÆDE, S. Y HELLEN, F. (2006): «Applying multri-criteria decision-making to protected areas and buffer zone management: A...
  • KASEMIR, B., GARDNER, M., JÄEGER, J. Y JAEGER, C (eds.) (2003): Public Participation in Sustainability Science, Cambridge University Press,...
  • KROTT, M., JULIEN, B., LAMMERTZ, M., BARBIER, J-M., JEN, S., BALLESTEROS, M. Y DE BOVIS, C. (2000): «Voicing Interests and Concerns. Natura...
  • LAIRD, F. (1993): «Participatory Analysis, Democracy, and Technological Decision Making», Science, Technology & Human Values, 18: 341-361.
  • MCCAULEY, D. (2008): «Sustainable development and the “Governance challenge”: the French experience with Natura 2000», European Environment,...
  • MESSNER, F., ZWIRNER, O. Y KARKUSCHKE, M. (2006): «Participation in multi-criteria decision support for the resolution of a water allocation...
  • MUNDA, G. (2004): «Social multi-criteria evaluation: Methodological foundations and operational consequences», European Journal of Operational...
  • MUNDA, G. 2005: «“Measuring sustainability”: A multi-criterion framework», Environment, Development and Sustainability, 7: 117-134.
  • MUNDA, G. 2006: «Social Multi-Criteria Evaluation for urban sustainability policies», Land Use Policy, 23: 86-94.
  • MUNDA, G. 2008: Social Multi-Criteria Evaluation for a sustainable economy, Springer, Verlag-BerlinHeidelberg.
  • NAJAM, A., PAPA, M. Y TAIYAB, N. (2006): Global environmental governance: A reform agenda, International Institute for Sustainable Development,...
  • NIEMELÄ, J., YOUNG, J., ALARD, D., ASKASIBAR, M., HENLE, K., JOHNSON, R., KURTTILA, M., LARSSON, T-B.; MATOUCH, S., NOWICKI, P., PAIVA, R.,...
  • NIJKAMP, P., RIETVELD, P. Y VOOGD, H. (1990): Multicriteria Evaluation in Physical planning, Elsevier, Amsterdan.
  • NUNES, P.A.L.D., VAN DEN BERGH, J.C.J.M. Y NIJKAMP, P. (2003): The Ecological Economics of Biodiversity. Methods and Policy Applications,...
  • O’CONNOR, M., FAUXCHEUX, S., FORGER, G., FUNTOWICZ, S. Y MUNDA, G. (1996): «Emergent Com- plexity and Procedural Rationality: Post-Normal...
  • O’RIORDAN, T. (2002): «Protecting beyond the protected», en O’Riordan, T. y Stoll-Kleemann, S. (eds.), Biodiversity, sustainability and human...
  • PAAVOLA, J. (2004): «Protected areas governance and justice: theory and the European Union’s Habitats Directive», Journal of Integrative Environmental...
  • PAAVOLA, J. 2007: «Institutions and environmental governance: A reconceptualization», Ecological Economics, 63: 93-103.
  • PAAVOLA, J. Y ADGER, W.N. (2005): «Institutional ecological economics», Ecological Economics, 53: 353-368.
  • PAAVOLA, J., GOULDSON, A. Y KLUVÁNKOVÁ-ORAVSKÁ, T. (2009): «Interplay of actors, scales, frameworks and regimes in the governance of biodiversity»,...
  • PAHL-WOSTL, C., CRAPS, M., DEWULF, A., MOSTERT, E., TABARA, D. Y TAILLIEU, T. (2007): «Social learning and water resource management», Ecology...
  • PARSON, E.A. Y CLARK, W.C. (1991): «Sustainable development as social learning: Theoretical perspectives and practical challenges for the...
  • PROCTOR, W. Y DRECHSLER, M. (2006): «Deliberative multicriteria evaluation», Environmental and Planning C: Government and Policy, 24: 169-190.
  • RAUSCHMAYER, F., PAAVOLA, J. Y WITTMER, H. (2009): «European governance of natural resources and participation in a multi-level context: an...
  • RAUSCHMAYER, F. Y WITTMER, H. (2006): «Evaluating deliberative and analytical methods for the resolution of environmental conflicts«, Land...
  • REED, M.S. (2008): «Stakeholder participation for environmental management: A literature review», Biological Conservation, 141: 2417-2431.
  • ROCA, E., GAMBOA, G. Y TÀBARA, D. (2008): «Assessing the multimensionality of coastal erosion risks. Public participation and multicriteria...
  • RODELA, R. Y UDOč, A. (2008): «Participation in nature protection: Does it benefit the local community? A Triglav National Park case study»,...
  • RUSSI, D. (2007): Social Multi-Criteria Evaluation and Renewable Energy Policies: Two case-studies, Tesis Doctoral, Universitat Autònoma de...
  • SCHUSLER, M., DECKER, D. Y PFEFFER, M. (2003): «Social Learning for Collaborative Natural Resource Management», Society and Natural Resources,...
  • SMITH, P.G.R. Y THEBERGE, J.B. (1987): «Evaluating natural areas using multiple criteria: Theory and practice», Environmental Management,...
  • SOCIAL LEARNING GROUP (2001): «Learning to Manage Global Environmental Risks», Volume 2. A Functional Analysis of Social Responses to Climate...
  • STIGLITZ, J.E. (2002): «New Perspectives on public f inance: Recent achievements and future challenges», Journal of Public Economics, 86:...
  • STIRLING, A. (2006): «Analysis, participation and power: justification and closure in participatory multi-criteria analysis», Land Use Policy,...
  • STRIEGNITZ, M. (2006): «Conflicts over coastal protection in a National Park: Mediation and negotiated law making», Land Use Policy, 23: 26-33.
  • STRIJKER, D., SIJTSMA, F.J. Y WIERSMA, D. (2000): «Evaluation of nature conservation: An application to the Dutch Ecological Network», Environmental...
  • VAN DEN HOVE, S. (2006): «Between consensus and compromise: acknowledging the negotiation dimension in participatory approaches», Land Use...
  • VAN PELT, M., KUYVENHOVEN, A. Y NIJKAMP, P. (1990): «Project appraisal and sustainability: the applicability of cost-benefit and multi-criteria...
  • VISSER, M., MORAN, J., REGAN, E., GORMALLY, M. Y SKEFFINGTON, M.S. (2007): «The Irish agri-environment: How turlough users and non-users view...
  • WEBLER, T., KASTENHOLZ, H. Y RENN, O. (1995): «Public participation in impact assessment: a social learning perspective», Environmental Impact...
  • WEBLER, T., TULER, S. Y KRUEGER, R. (2001): «What is a good public participation process? Five perspectives from the public·, Environmental...
  • WEBLER, T., TULER, S. Y TANGUAY, J. (2004): «Competing perspectives on public participation in National Park Service Planning: The Boston...
  • WEBLER, T. Y TULER, S. (2006): «Four perspectives on public participation process in environmental assessment and decision making», Policy...
  • WITTMER, H., RAUSCHMAYER, F. Y KLAUER, B. (2006): «How to select instruments for the resolution of environmental conflicts?», Land Use Policy,...
  • WYNNE, B. (1992): «Uncertainty and environmental learning Reconceiving science and policy in the preventive paradigm», Global Environmental...