Enhancing the Scrutiny Role of Select Committees: The House of Commons Health and Social Care Select Committee’s New Independent Expert Panel

• Peckham, Stephen ^[1] ; Jane Dacre, Dame ^[2] ; Appleby, John ^[3] ; Charlesworth, Anita ^[4] ; Francis, Robert ^[5]
  1. [1] University of Kent

     University of Kent

     City of Canterbury, Reino Unido

     
  2. [2] University College London

     University College London

     Reino Unido

     
  3. [3] Nuffield Trust
  4. [4] Health Foundation
  5. [5] Serjeants Inn Chambers

  Mostrar afiliaciones +
• Localización: Parliamentary affairs: A journal of representative politics, ISSN 0031-2290, Vol. 77, Nº 2, 2024, págs. 262-284
• Idioma: inglés
• DOI: 10.1093/pa/gsac025
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Resumen

  • We report on a recent innovation for one Departmental Select Committee. While government policy commitments are well publicised, little attention is paid to the quality of commitments made or to assessing progress against those commitments. In 2020, the Health and Social Care Select Committee commissioned an Expert Panel to conduct independent, in-depth evaluations of government progress on selected policy commitments. The first evaluations in 2021/22 assessed commitments in maternity, mental health and cancer services, and workforce and it was the first time a government department has been systematically graded against its own commitments. This is an important new method of scrutiny with the potential to complement and enhance the work of Select Committee inquiries. This paper reviews the development of select committees highlighting issues relating to their operation and, in particular, assessment of evidence. We describe the innovation of the Expert Panel and its role in reviewing policy commitments and discuss implications for parliamentary scrutiny, leadership and improvements to health service.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Aylett, P. (2016) ‘Thirty Years of Reform: House of Commons Select Committees, 1960- 1990’, PhD Thesis, University of London, accessed at...
  • Aylett, P. (2019) ‘Reform and consolidation: A new perspective on Commons Select Committees 1960–1980’, Parliamentary Affairs, 72, 742–760.
  • Beebe, J. (2014) Rapid Qualitative Inquiry: A Field Guide to Team-Based Assessment. Rowman & Littlefield.
  • Benton, M. and Russell, M. (2013) ‘Assessing the Impact of Parliamentary Oversight Committees: The Select Committees in the British House...
  • Beswick, D. and Elstub, S. (2019) ‘Between Diversity, Representation and ‘Best Evidence’: Rethinking Select Committee Evidence-Gathering Practices’,...
  • Binderkrantz, A. S., Christiansen, P. M. and Pedersen, H. H. (2015) ‘Interest Group Access to the Bureaucracy, Parliament, and the Media’,...
  • Bochel, H. and Berthier, A. (2018) Committee Witnesses: Gender and Representation (No. SB 18–16). Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament Information...
  • Boswell, C. (2018) Manufacturing Political Trust: Targets and Performance Management in Public Policy. Washington, DC.: Cambridge: Cambridge...
  • Coleman, A., Billings, J., Allen, P., et al. (2021) ‘Ambiguity and Conflict in Policy Implementation: The Case of the New Care Models (Vanguard)...
  • Committee of Privileges. (2021). Select committees and contempts: clarifying and strengthening powers to call for persons, papers and records....
  • Compton, M. E. and t’Hart, P. (2020) ‘How to “See” Great Policy Successes’. In t’Hart, P. and Compton M. E. (eds) Great Policy Successes....
  • Dacre, J., Francis, R., Appleby, J., Charlesworth, A., Peckham, S., Bhui, K., Dave, A., Fonagy, P. and Turner, K. (2021a) The Health and Social...
  • Dacre, J., Francis, R., Appleby, J., Charlesworth, A., Peckham, S., Augst, C., Kaur, M., Downe, S., Heazell, A., Noble, S. and Regan, L. (2021b)...
  • Dacre J., Francis R., Appleby J., et al. (2022) Expert Panel: Evaluation of the Government’s Commitments in the Area of Cancer Services in...
  • Drewry, G. (ed.) (1985) The New Select Committees: A Study of the 1979 Reforms. Oxford: Clarendon.
  • Dunleavy, P. (2013) ‘Written Evidence Submitted by Professor Patrick Dunleavy, Co-director of Democratic Audit’ in House of Commons Political...
  • Dunleavy, P. and Muir, D. (2013) Parliament Bounces Back – How Select Committees Have Become a Power in the Land Democratic Audit Blog (18...
  • Dunleavy P. (2018) How Effective Are the Commons’ Two Committee Systems at Scrutinising Government Policy-Making? Democratic Audit https://www.democraticaudit. com/2018/09/24/audit2018-how-effective-are-the-commons-two-committee-systems- at-scrutinising-government-policy-making/...
  • Eising, R. and Spohr, F. (2017) ‘The More, the Merrier? Interest Groups and Legislative Change in the Public Hearings of the German Parliamentary...
  • Geddes, M. (2018) ‘Committee Hearings of the UK Parliament: Who Gives Evidence and Does This Matter?’, Parliamentary Affairs, 71, 283–304.
  • Geddes, M. (2021) The Webs of Belief Around ‘Evidence’ in Select Committees in the UK House of Commons. Public Admin, 99, 40–54.
  • Health & Social Care Committee. (2020) Process for Independent Evaluation of Progress on Government Commitments, Paragraph 1. 5 August...
  • HoC. (2018) Standing Order No. 152. London: House of Commons.
  • House of Commons Liaison Committee. (2000) First Report: Shifting the Balance: Select Committees and the Executive (HC 300). London: HMSO.
  • House of Commons Political and Constitutional Reform Committee. (2013) Revisiting Rebuilding the House: the Impact of the Wright Reforms....
  • Hudson, B., Hunter, D. J. and Peckham, S. (2019) ‘Policy Failure and the Policy- Implementation Gap: Can Policy Support Programmes Help?’,...
  • Involve. (2018) Citizens’ Assembly on Social care Recommendations for funding Adult Social Care. London: Involve/House of Commons.
  • Law Commission. (2006) Post-Legislative Scrutiny. London: Law Commission.
  • LSE GV314 Group. (2020) ‘UK Parliamentary Select Committees: Crowdsourcing for Evidence-Based Policy or Grandstanding?,’ Journal of Legislative...
  • Maer L (2009) The Departmental Select Committee System. London: House of Commons Library.
  • Mays, N. (2013) ‘Evaluating the Labour Government’s English NHS Health System Reforms: The 2008 Darzi Reforms’, Journal of Health Services...
  • Moore, G., Redman, S., Rudge, S. and Haynes, A. (2018) ‘Do Policy-Makers Find Commissioned Rapid Reviews Useful?’, Health Research Policy...
  • Peckham, S., Hudson, B., Hunter, D. and Redgate, S. (2021) ‘Policy Success: What is the Role of Implementation Support Programmes?’, Social...
  • Pedersen, H. H., Halpen, D. and Rasmussen, A. (2015) ‘Who Gives Evidence to Parliamentary Committees? A Comparative Investigation of Parliamentary...
  • Pow, J. (2021) ‘Mini-Publics and the Wider Public: The Perceived Legitimacy of Randomly Selecting Citizen Representatives’, Representation,...
  • Prescott, C. (2019) ‘Select Committees: Understanding and Regulating the Emergence of the ‘Topical Inquiry’, Parliamentary Affairs, 72, 879–902.
  • Rumbul, R. (2016) ‘Gender Inequality in Democratic Participation: Examining Oral Evidence to the National Assembly for Wales’, Politics, 36,...
  • Secretary of State for Health and Social Care. (2021) The Government’s response to the Health and Social Care Committee’s Expert Panel Evaluation....
  • Secretary of State for Health and Social Care. (2022) The Government’s response to the Health and Social Care Committee’s Expert Panel Evaluation....
  • Select Committee on Procedure. (1978) ‘First Report, 17 July 1978, HC 588-I 1997-78, para 5.7’. In The Departmental Select Committee System....
  • Turnpenny, J., Russel, D. and Rayner, T. (2012) ‘The Complexity of Evidence for Sustainable Development Policy: Analysing the Boundary Work...
  • White H (2015) Parliamentary Scrutiny of Government. London: Institute of Government