House of Commons Public Bill Committees and Oral Evidence: A Half-Step Forward?

• Bochel, Hugh M ^[1]
  1. [1] University of Lincoln

     University of Lincoln

     Lincoln District, Reino Unido

     
• Localización: Parliamentary affairs: A journal of representative politics, ISSN 0031-2290, Vol. 77, Nº 1, 2024, págs. 129-148
• Idioma: inglés
• DOI: 10.1093/pa/gsac013
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Resumen

  • The introduction of evidence sessions for House of Commons public bill committees in 2007, including oral evidence from witnesses, was widely seen as a potentially significant improvement in informing scrutiny of legislation. Drawing on interviews with officials and witnesses, and on data gathered from Hansard for the 2017–2019 session, this article examines the selection and some of the characteristics of witnesses, witnesses’ views of the process and how oral evidence is used in subsequent scrutiny of the legislation. While recognising that oral evidence does make an important contribution to scrutiny, the article notes that both the process as it currently exists, and the inevitable influence of political factors, mean that the impact of oral evidence on legislation remains very limited.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Begley, P., Bochel, C., Bochel. H., Defty, A., Gordon, J., Hinkkainen, K., Kisby, B., McKay, S., and Strange, G. (2019) ‘Evidence-informed...
  • Berry, R. and Kippin, S. (2014) Parliamentary Select Committees: Who Gives Evidence?, London, Democratic Audit.
  • Besley, N., Goldsmith, T., Rogers, R. and Walters, R. (2019) How Parliament Works, London, Routledge.
  • Beswick, D. and Elstub, S. (2019) ‘Between Diversity, Representation and “Best Evidence”: Rethinking Select Committee Evidence-Gathering Practices’,...
  • Bochel, H. and Berthier, A. (2018) Committee Witnesses: Gender and Representation, Edinburgh, Scottish Parliament Information Centre.
  • Bochel, H. and Berthier, A. (2021) ‘Committees and Witnesses in the Scottish Parliament: Beyond the “Usual Suspects”?’, Scottish Affairs,...
  • Bochel, H. and Defty, A. (2010) ‘A Question of Expertise: The House of Lords and Welfare Policy’, Parliamentary Affairs, 63, 66–84.
  • Bochel, H. and Duncan, S. (eds) (2007) Making Policy in Theory and Practice, Bristol, The Policy Press.
  • Brazier, A., Kalitowski, S., Rosenblatt, G. and Korris, M. (2008) Law in the Making, London, Hansard Society.
  • Cabinet Office (2017) Guide to Making Legislation, London, Cabinet Office. Commission to Strengthen Parliament (2000) Strengthening Parliament:...
  • Cowley, P. and Stuart, M. (2008) Better than Nowt, But Still a Missed Opportunity, accessed at http://www.revolts.co.uk/ on 19 November 2014.
  • Defty, A. and White, H. (2018) ‘Evidence from Outside’, In Leston-Bandeira, C. and Thompson, L. (eds) Exploring Parliament, Oxford, Oxford...
  • Fox, R. and Korris, M. (2010) Making Better Law: Reform of the Legislative Process from Policy to Act, London, Hansard Society.
  • Geddes, M. (2018) ‘Committee Hearings of the UK Parliament: Who Gives Evidence and Does This Matter?’, Parliamentary Affairs, 71, 283–304.
  • Guardian Politics Live (2021) Accessed at https://www.theguardian.com/politics/live/ 2021/sep/21/boris-johnson-brexit-uk-us-trade-biden-energy-covid-coronavirus-livelatest- updates?page=with:block-6149f6c88f084d4bbdefebd8...
  • House of Commons Hansard (2021) Accessed at https://hansard.parliament.uk/com mons/2021-09-21/debates/e38b689e-afd4-446a-b6d3-72a9eeb419d8/ NationalityAndBordersBill(FirstSitting)...
  • House of Commons (2019) Sessional Returns: Session 2017–19, London, House of Commons.
  • House of Commons Liaison Committee (2018) Witness Gender Diversity, London, House of Commons.
  • House of Lords Constitution Committee (2019a) The Legislative Process: The Passage of Bills through Parliament, London, House of Lords.
  • House of Lords Constitution Committee (2019b) Government Response to House of Lords Constitution Committee: The Legislative Process: The Passage...
  • House of Lords Hansard (2019) Accessed at https://hansard.parliament.uk/lords/2019- 02-06/debates/E9C146E1-0A1C-4D4B-B0B3-707125254FCF/OffensiveWeaponsBill...
  • Kelso, A. (2009) Parliamentary Reform at Westminster, Manchester, Manchester University Press.
  • Kenny, C., Rose, D., Hobbs, A., Tyler, C. and Blackstock, J. (2017) The Role of Research in the UK Parliament, vol. 1, London, Houses of Parliament.
  • Levy, J. (2010) ‘Public Bill Committees: An Assessment Scrutiny Sought; Scrutiny Gained’, Parliamentary Affairs, 63, 534–544.
  • LSE GV314 Group (2020) ‘UK Parliamentary Select Committees: Crowdsourcing for Evidence-Based Policy or Grandstanding?’, Journal of Legislative...
  • Modernisation Committee (2006) Modernisation of the House of Commons, London, House of Commons.
  • Newman, J. (2001) Modernising Governance, London, Sage.
  • Norton, P. (2013) Parliament in British Politics, Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan.
  • Pedersen, H., Halpin, D. and Rasmussen, A. (2015) ‘Who Gives Evidence to Parliamentary Committees? A Comparative Investigation of Parliamentary Committees...
  • Russell, M. and Benton, M. (2009) Professional and Other Diversity in the House of Lords: Report to the House of Lords Appointment Commission,...
  • Russell, M. and Gover, D. (2017) Legislation at Westminster: Parliamentary Actors and Influence in the Making of British Law, Oxford, Oxford...
  • Russell, M., Morris, B. and Larkin, P. (2013) Fitting the Bill: Bringing Commons Legislative Committees into Line with Best Practice, London,...
  • Scottish Parliament Equalities and Human Rights Committee (2019) ‘Agenda’. Accessed at https://archive2021.parliament.scot/S5_Equal_Opps/EHRiC_Papers_20191107.pdf on...
  • Select Committee on the Constitution (2004) The Legislative Process, London, House of Lords.
  • Thompson, L. (2013) ‘More of the Same or a Period of Change? The Impact of Bill Committees in the Twenty-First Century House of Commons’,...
  • Thompson, L. (2014) ‘Evidence Taking under the Microscope: How Has Oral Evidence Affected the Scrutiny of Legislation in House of Commons...
  • Thompson, L. (2015) Making British Law: Committees in Action, Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan.
  • Thompson, L. (2016) ‘Debunking the Myths of Bill Committees in the British House of Commons’, Politics, 36, 36–48.
  • Tyrie, A. (2000) Mr Blair’s Poodle: An Agenda for Reviving the House of Commons, London, Centre for Policy Studies.