Implementing Public Accounts Committee Recommendations: Evidence from the UK Government’s ‘Progress Reports’ since 2012

Thomas Elston; Yuxi Zhang

Implementing Public Accounts Committee Recommendations: Evidence from the UK Government’s ‘Progress Reports’ since 2012

Elston, Thomas ^[1] ; Zhang, Yuxi ^[2]
1. [1] University of Oxford
  
  University of Oxford
  
  Oxford District, Reino Unido
2. [2] London School of Economics and Political Science
  
  London School of Economics and Political Science
  
  Reino Unido
Localización: Parliamentary affairs: A journal of representative politics, ISSN 0031-2290, Vol. 76, Nº 3, 2023, págs. 662-693
Idioma: inglés
DOI: 10.1093/pa/gsab068
Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
Resumen
- The Public Accounts Committee is the oldest and, reputedly, most influential oversight committee in the British parliament. Since 2012, the government has published an unprecedented volume of data explaining its actions in response to the PAC’s inquiries. By tracking all 615 of the Committee’s recommendations from 2010 to 2012 across the first 14 of these ‘progress reports’, we explore how effectively this novel reporting mechanism serves to inform parliament about the executive’s responsiveness to scrutiny. We find the reports to yield rich data on the fate of many individual recommendations, but only limited information on the overall timeliness and quality of implementation. Flexibilities and inconsistencies in reporting style also make the arrangements vulnerable to gaming. We identify potential improvements and research opportunities.
Referencias bibliográficas
- Aldons, M. (2000) ‘Rating the Effectiveness of Committee Reports: Some Examples’, Australian Parliamentary Review, 16, 52–99.
- Altman, D. (1999) Practical Statistics for Medical Research. Boca Raton, FL, Chapman & Hall/CRC.
- Anand, P. (1988) ‘Monitoring and Auditing Value for Money in the UK: The Scope for Quantitative Analysis’, Financial Accountability and Management,...
- Aylett, P. (2019) ‘Reform and Consolidation: A New Perspective on Commons Select Committees 1960–1980’, Parliamentary Affairs, 72, 742–760.
- Benton, M. and Russell, M. (2013) ‘Assessing the Impact of Parliamentary Oversight Committees: The Select Committees in the British House...
- Bevan, G. and Hood, C. (2006) ‘What’s Measured Is What Matters: Targets and Gaming in the English Public Healthcare System’, Public Administration,...
- Bolton, A., Potter, R. and Thrower, S. (2016) ‘Organizational Capacity, Regulatory Review, and the Limits of Political Control’, Journal of...
- Boswell, C. (2009) The Political Uses of Expert Knowledge, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
- Bovens, M. A. R. K., Schillemans, T. and Hart, P. (2008) ‘Does Public Accountability Work?’, Public Administration, 86, 225–242.
- Brazier, A. and Fox, R. (2011) ‘Reviewing Select Committee Tasks and Modes of Operation’, Parliamentary Affairs, 64, 354–369.
- Bringselius, L. (2014) ‘The Dissemination of Results from Supreme Audit Institutions: Independent Partners with the Media?’, Financial Accountability...
- Campbell, D. (1979) ‘Assessing the Impact of Planned Social Change’, Evaluation and Program Planning, 2, 67–90.
- Caruana, J. and Farrugia, B. (2018) ‘The Use and Non-use of the Government Financial Report by Maltese Members of Parliament’, Accounting,...
- Chapman, L. (1978) Your Disobedient Servant. London: Chatto and Windus. Constitution Committee. (2013) The Pre-emption of Parliament (HL 165,...
- Dewar, D. and Funnell, W. (2016) A History of British National Audit. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Drewry, G. (ed.) (1985) The New Select Committees. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
- Drolc, C. and Keiser, L. (2021) ‘The Importance of Oversight and Agency Capacity in Enhancing Performance in Public Service Delivery’, Journal...
- Dubnick, M. (2005) ‘Accountability and the Promise of Performance’, Public Performance & Management Review, 28, 376–417.
- Dunleavy, P. and Muir, D. (2013) Parliament Bounces Back—How Select Committees Have Become a Power in the Land. Democratic Audit. Retrieved...
- Elston, T. (2013) ‘Developments in UK Executive Agencies: Re-examining the “Disaggregation-Reaggregation” Thesis’, Public Policy and Administration,...
- Elston, T. and Bevan, G. (2020) ‘Using Opportunity Costs to Counter “One-Shot” Bias in Policy Innovation’. In Sullivan H. and Dickinson H....
- Flesher, D. and Zarzeski, M. (2002) ‘The Roots of Operational (Value-for-Money) Auditing in English-Speaking Nations’. Accounting and Business...
- Flinders, M. (2012) Defending Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Foster, D. (2015) ‘Going “Where Angels Fear to Tread”: How Effective Was the Backbench Business Committee in the 2010–2012 Parliamentary Session?’, Parliamentary...
- Gaines, B., Goodwin, M., Bates, S. and Sin, G. (2019) ‘A Bouncy House? UK Select Committee Newsworthiness, 2005–18’, The Journal of Legislative...
- Geddes, M. (2018) ‘Committee Hearings of the UK Parliament: Who Gives Evidence and Does This Matter?’, Parliamentary Affairs, 71, 283–304.
- Geddes, M. (2020) Dramas at Westminster. Manchester: Manchester University Press. Hansard Society. (2001) The Challenge for Parliament. London:...
- Hindmoor, A., Larkin, P. and Kennon, A. (2009) ‘Assessing the Influence of Select Committees in the UK: The Education and Skills Committee,...
- HM Treasury. (2015) The Accounting Officer’s Survival Guide. London.
- Hodge, M. (2016) Called to Account. London: Little, Brown.
- Hood, C. (1976) The Limits of Administration. London: Wiley.
- Hood, C. and Himaz, R. (2017) A Century of Fiscal Squeeze Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Judge, D. (1992) ‘The “Effectiveness” of the Post-1979 Select Committee System: The Verdict of the 1990 Procedure Committee’, The Political...
- Keane, J. (2009) The Life and Death of Democracy. London: Simon and Schuster.
- Kells, S. (2011) ‘The Seven Deadly Sins of Performance Auditing: Implications for Monitoring Public Audit Institutions’, Australian Accounting...
- Kelman, S. and Friedman, J. (2009) ‘Performance Improvement and Performance Dysfunction: An Empirical Examination of Distortionary Impacts...
- King, A. (1981) ‘How to Strengthen Legislatures—Assuming That We Want to’. In Ornstein NJ (ed.) The Role of the Legislature in Western Democracies....
- Kubala, M. (2011) ‘Select Committees in the House of Commons and the Media’, Parliamentary Affairs, 64, 694–713.
- Landis, J. and Koch, G. (1977) ‘The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data’, Biometrics, 33, 159–174.
- Liaison Committee. (2019) The Effectiveness and Influence of the Select Committee System (HC 1860, Session 2017–19). London: The Stationery...
- Lonsdale, J. (2008) ‘Balancing Independence and Responsiveness: A Practitioner Perspective on the Relationships Shaping Performance Audit’,...
- Lupia, A. (2003) ‘Delegation and Its Perils’. In Strøm K., Müller W. C. and Bergman T. (eds) Delegation and Accountability in Parliamentary...
- Matthews, F. (2020) ‘Parliamentary Scrutiny of Executive Patronage: The Relationship between Institutional Norms, Reputation and Accountability’,...
- Mattson, I. and Strøm, K. (1995) ‘Parliamentary Committees’. In Döring H. (ed.) Parliaments and Majority Rule in Western Europe. Frankfurt,...
- Midgley, H. (2019) ‘The National Audit Office and the Select Committee System 1979–2019’, Parliamentary Affairs, 72, 779–798.
- Morin, D. (2001) ‘Influence of Value for Money Audit on Public Administrations: Looking beyond Appearances’, Financial Accountability &...
- Morin, D. (2008) ‘Auditors General’s Universe Revisited: An Exploratory Study of the Influence They Exert on Public Administration through...
- Moynihan, D. (2016) ‘Political Use of Performance Data’, Public Money & Management, 36, 479–481.
- National Audit Office (NAO). (2020) Annual Report and Accounts, 2019–20. (HC 373 Session 2019–2021). London.
- NAO. (2021) History of the NAO. Retrieved 24 March 2021 from: https://www.nao.org. uk/about-us/our-work/history-of-the-nao/.
- Pelizzo, R., Stapenhurst, R., Sahgal, V. and Woodley, W. (2006) ‘What Makes Public Accounts Committees Work? A Comparative Analysis: What...
- Pollitt, C., Girre, X., Lonsdale, J., Mul, R., Summa, H. and Waerness, M. (1999) Performance or Compliance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Powell, G. (2000) Elections as Instruments of Democracy. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
- Power, M. (1997) The Audit Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Procedure Committee. (2019) Should There Be a Commons Budget Committee? (HC 1482, Session 2017–19). London: The Stationery Office.
- Propper, C. and Wilson, D. (2003) ‘The Use and Usefulness of Performance Measures in the Public Sector’, Oxford Review of Economic Policy,...
- Public Accounts Committee (PAC). (2007) Holding Government to account: 150 Years of the Committee of Public Accounts. London.
- PAC. (2015) The Work of the Committee of Public Accounts 2010–15 (HC 1141). London: The Stationery Office.
- Rhodes, R. (2011) Everyday Life in British Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Robinson, A. (1985) ‘The Financial Work of the Select Committees’. In Drewry G. (ed.) The New Select Committees, Oxford, Clarendon Press,...
- Rogers, R., Walters, R., Besly, N. and Goldsmith, T. (2019) How Parliament Works. London: Routledge.
- Russell, M. (2011) ‘Never Allow a Crisis to Go to Waste’: The Wright Committee Reforms to Strengthen the House of Commons’, Parliamentary...
- Russell, M. and Gover, D. (2017) Legislation at Westminster. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Staddon, A. (2015) ‘The Public Accounts Committee of the House of Commons’. In Hoque Z. (ed.) Making Governments Accountable. Routledge.
- Stark, A. (2019) ‘Policy Learning and the Public Inquiry’, Policy Sciences, 52, 397–417.
- Strøm, K. (2000) ‘Delegation and Accountability in Parliamentary Democracies’, European Journal of Political Research, 37, 261–290.
- Talbot, C. (2010) Performance in Government: The Evolving System of Performance and Evaluation, Measurement, Monitoring and Management in...
- Talbot, C. and Wiggan, J. (2010) ‘The Public Value of the National Audit Office’, International Journal of Public Sector Management, 23, 54–70.
- Walgrave, S. and Dejaeghere, Y. (2017) ‘Surviving Information Overload: How Elite Politicians Select Information’, Governance, 30, 229–244.
- Wehner, J. (2003) ‘Principles and patterns of financial scrutiny: Public Accounts Committees in the Commonwealth’, Commonwealth & Comparative...
- White, F. and Hollingsworth, K. (1999) Audit, Accountability and Government. Oxford: Clarendon Press.