Ponderando direitos e interesses: Objeções à tese da assimetria de Frederick Schauer

• Klatt, Matthias ^[1]
  1. [1] Karl-Franzens-Universitaet Graz
• Localización: Revista Brasileira de Direito, ISSN-e 2238-0604, Vol. 17, Nº. 1, 2021 (Ejemplar dedicado a: RBD. Jan-Abr/2021; e4456)
• Idioma: portugués
• DOI: 10.18256/2238-0604.2021.v17i1.4495
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo (pdf)
• Resumen

  • Fred Schauer argumenta que o último passo do teste de proporcionalidade, a ponderação, está sujeita a uma assimetria significativa. Embora se pudesse ponderar interesses, direitos não poderiam ser ponderados, sob pena do status normativo dos direitos ser destruído. Se essa assimetria existir, a aplicabilidade da ponderação seria significativamente limitada. Inicialmente, será analisada a tese da assimetria e discutido os seus pontos fortes e fracos. Em seguida, será demonstrado a possibilidade de acomodar os fundamentos da tese de Schauer em consideração a ponderação na teoria dos princípios. Por fim, a tese de Schauer será rejeitada. Este artigo confirma que a aplicação da proporcionalidade suporta a ponderação de direitos e interesses.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • ALEXY, Robert. A Theory of Constitutional Rights. Translation: Julian Rivers. Oxford University Press. 2002.
  • ALEXY, Robert. Die Gewichtsformel. In. JICKELI, Joachim; KREUTZ, Peter; REUTER, Dieter. (Orgs). Gedächtnisschrift für Jürgen Sonnenschein....
  • ALEXY, Robert. Formal principles: Some replies to critics. International Journal of Constitutional Law, v. 12. 2014.
  • ALEXY, Robert. Postscript, A Theory of Constitutional Rights. Translation Julian Rivers. Oxford University Press, 2002.
  • ALEXY, Robert. Proportionality, constitutional law, and sub-constitutional law: A reply to Aharon Barak. International Journal of Constitutional...
  • ALEXY, Robert. The Absolute and the Relative Dimension of Constitutional Rights. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, v. 37, n. 1, 2017.
  • ALEXY, Robert. The Weight Formula. In. STELMACH, Jerzy; BARTOSZ, Brozek; ZALUSKI, Wojciech. (Orgs), Studies in the Philosophy of Law. Frontiers...
  • BADENHOP, Johannes. Normtheoretische Grundlagen der Europäischen Menschenrechtskonvention. Nomos. 2010.
  • BARAK, Aharon. Proportionality and Principled Balancing. Law & Etichs of Human Rights, v. 4, 2010.
  • BEATTY, Devid M. The Ultimate Rule of Law. New York: Oxford University Press, 2004.
  • BOROWSKI, Martin. Limiting Clauses: On the Continental European Tradition of Special Limiting Clauses and the General Limiting Clause of Art...
  • BVerfGE 13, 97 (Handwerksordnung) (1961) 1 BvL 44/55 13 BVerfGE 97 (BVerfG).
  • KLATT, Matthias. ‘Positive Obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights. HJIL 681. 2011.
  • KLATT, Matthias. A discricionariedade epistemica no direito constitucional: Trad. Fausto Santo de Morais. In. MORAIS, Fausto S d; BORTOLOTI,...
  • KLATT, Matthias. An Egalitarian Defense of Proportionality-Based Balancing: A Response to Luc B. Tremblay. 12(4) Int’l J Const L 891. 2014.
  • KLATT, Matthias. Epistemic Discretion in Constitutional Law. 10(1) Int’l J Const L 69. 2012.
  • KLATT, Matthias. Proportionality and Justification. In. HERLIN-KARNELL, Ester; KLATT, Matthias (eds). Constitutionalism Justified: Rainer...
  • KLATT, Matthias. The Legitimacy of Constitution-Conform Interpretation. 2019.
  • KLATT, Matthias; MEISTER, Moritz. Proportionality - A Benefit to Human Rights?: Remarks on the ICon Controversy. 10(3) Int’l J Const L 687....
  • KLATT, Matthias; MEISTER, Moritz. The constitutional structure of proportionality. Oxford Univ. Press, 2012.
  • KLATT, Matthias; SCHMIDT, J. Spielräume im Öffentlichen Recht: Zur Abwägungslehre der Prinzipientheorie. Mohr Siebeck, 2010.
  • MEISTER, Moritz. Das System des Freiheitsschutzes im Grundgesetz. Editora Duncker & Humblot, 2011.
  • MÖLLER Kai. The Global Model of Constitutional Rights. USA. Oxford University Press, 2012.
  • PULIDO. Carlos Bernal. On Alexy’s Weight Formula’. In. MENÉNDEZ, Agustín J; ERIKSEN, Erik O. Arguing Fundamental Rights. Law and Philosophy...
  • RAWLS, John. A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, Massachusetts: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1971.
  • RAWLS, John. Political liberalism. The John Dewey essays in philosophy. vol 4. Columbia Univ. Press, 1993.
  • RIVERS, Julian. A theory of constitutional rights and the British constitution. A Theory of Constitutional Rights. Translation: Julian Rivers....
  • SCHAUER, Frederich. Proportionality and the Question of Weight. In. HUSCROFT, Grant; MILLER, Bradley W; WEBBER, Grégoire C N. (orgs). Proportionality...
  • SILVA, Virgílio Afonso da. Comparing the Incommensurable: Constitutional Principles, Balancing and Rational Decision. Oxford Journal of Legal...
  • TSAKYRAKIS, Stavros. Proportionality: An Assault on Human Rights?. International Journal of Constitutional Law, v. 7, i. 3, p. 468-493.