Educational services, common commercial policy and breach of WTO provisions: the CJEU’s perspective in the Central European University Case (Case C-66/18)

• Autores: Andres Delgado Casteleiro, Cristina Contartese
• Localización: Revista General de Derecho Europeo, ISSN-e 1696-9634, Nº. 54, 2021
• Idioma: inglés
• Títulos paralelos:
  • Servicios de educación, política comercial común y la violación de preceptos de la omc: La perspectiva de la cjue en asunto central european university (asunto c-66/18)
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Dialnet Métricas: 2 Citas
• Resumen
  • español

    Comisión c. Hungría (C-66/18) resuelve un recurso de incumplimiento relativo a dos modificaciones de la ley que regula la educación superior en Hungría. Este comentario se centra en el análisis de la jurisdicción de la Corte de Justicia de la Unión Europea sobre acuerdos mixtos y su relación con el campo de aplicación de la Carta de Derechos Fundamentales. Asimismo, este comentario examina las consecuencias de esta sentencia sobre la s relaciones entre el Derecho de la UE y la OMC. La sentencia perpetua ciertas inequidades entre el rol de los Estados Miembros y la Comisión a la hora de prevenir violaciones de las obligaciones internacionales en el ordenamiento jurídico europeo

  • English

    The case Commission v Hungary (C-66/18) concerns an infringement proceeding on two amendments to the Hungarian Law on higher education. This note focuses on the aspects of the judgment concerning to the effects of the CJEU’s broadening jurisdiction on mixed agreements, as well as on the scope of application of the EU Charter vis-à-vis Member States. Moreover, this case note examines the consequences of the case upon the EU-WTO relations. This paper points the Court’s approach determines an imbalance between the role of the EU Member States and the Commission in preventing breaches of international obligations within the EU legal order.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • DRINÓCZI, T., BIEŃ-KACAŁA, A. (eds), Rule of law, common values, and illiberal constitutionalism: Poland and Hungary within the European Union...
  • NASIYA, D., “Rule of law vs. Poland and Hungary, an inconsistent approach?”, Hungarian journal of legal studies/Acta juridica hungarica, Vol....
  • WENNERÅS, P., “Saving a forest and the rule of law: Commission v Poland: case C-441/17 R, Commission v Poland, order of the Court (Grand Chamber)...
  • KELEMEN, R. D., PECH, L., “The uses and abuses of constitutional pluralism : undermining the rule of law in the name of constitutional identity...
  • LOCK T., The European Court of Justice and International Courts (Oxford University Press 2015).
  • KOUTRAKOS P., EU International Relations Law (Second Edition edn, Hart 2015).
  • KRAJEWSKI, M., “Of Modes and Sectors External Relations, Internal Debates, and the Special Case of (Trade in) Services” in CREMONA, M. (ed.),...
  • HERRMANN, C. W., “Common Commercial Policy After Nice: Sisyphus would have done a better job” 39 Common Market Law Review, n 7, 2002,, pp....
  • MELO ARAUJO, B. A., The EU Deep Trade Agenda: Law and Policy (Oxford University Press 2016).
  • EECKHOUT, P., EU External Relations Law (Second Edition edn, Oxford University Press 2011).
  • DIMOPOULOS, supra, note 26, p. 98; CEYSSENS, J., “Towards a Common Foreign Investment Policy? - Foreign Investment in the European Constitution”...
  • MARÍN DURÁN G., “Sustainable development chapters in EU free trade agreements: Emerging compliance issues”, Common Market Law Review, n 57...
  • LARIK, J., “No mixed feelings: The post-Lisbon Common Commercial Policy in Daiichi Sankyo and Commission v. Council (Conditional Access Convention)”,...
  • AZOULAI, L., “The Many Visions of Europe: Insights from the reasoning of the European Court of Justice in External Relations Law” in CREMONA...
  • DELGADO CASTELEIRO, A, “The Effects of International Dispute Settlement Decisions in EU Law” in CREMONA, M., THIES, A., WESSEL R.A. (eds),...
  • ROLDÁN BARBERO, J., “The Relationship the Member States’ International Agreements with the EU”, in Piet Eeckout and Manuel López Escudero...
  • DELGADO CASTELEIRO, A., “The International Responsibility of the EU: Between pragmatism and proceduralization”, Cambridge Yearbook of European...
  • DELGADO CASTELEIRO, A., The International Responsibility of the EU: From Competence to Normative Control (Cambridge University Press 2016).
  • CONTARTESE C., “Competence-Based Approach, Normative Control, and the International Responsibility of the EU and Its Member States”, International...
  • Hancox, E., “The meaning of “implementing” EU law under Article 51(1) of the Charter: Åkerberg Fransson”, Common Market Law Review, n. 50...
  • Sarmiento, D., “Who’s Afraid of the Charter? The Court Of Justice, National Courts and the New Framework of Fundamental Rights Protection...
  • NEFRAMI E, “Mixed Agreements as a source of European Union Law”, in CANNIZZARO, E., PALCHETTI, P., WESSEL R. A. (eds), International Law as...
  • EECKHOUT, P., “Case C-61/94, Commission v Germany, [1996] ECR I-3989”, 35 Common Market Law Review (1998), p. 557.
  • HERNÁNDEZ FERNÁNDEZ, F., “The application of WTO law in the EU after the case Commission v Hungary”, Revista General de Derecho Europeo, in...
  • DELGADO CASTELEIRO, A., CONTARTESE, C., “International Responsibility of the EU and/or its Member States in International Agreements: From...
  • KUIJPER, P. J, BRONCKERS, M., “WTO law in the European Court of Justice”, Common Market Law Review, n. 42, 2005, pp. 1348-1350, 1354-1355.
  • ZIEGLER, K. S., “Beyond Pluralism and Autonomy: Systemic Harmonization as a Paradigm for the Interaction of EU Law and International Law”,...
  • ECKES, C., “Protecting Supremacy from External Influences: A Precondition for a European Constitutional Legal Order?”, European Law Journal,...
  • KLABBERS, J., “Völkerrechtsfreundlich? International Law and the Union Legal Order”, in KOUTRAKOS, P. (ed.), European Foreign Policy Legal...
  • SKORDAS, A., “Völkerrechtsfreundlichkeit as comity and the disquiet of neoformalism: a response to Jan Klabbers”, in KOUTRAKOS, P. (ed.),...