Análisis jurídico y crítica de cláusulas de excepción entre el Reglamento Roma I y II y en otros reglamentos de la UE

• Dimitris Liakppoulos ^[1]
  1. [1] Tufts University

     Tufts University

     City of Medford, Estados Unidos

     
• Localización: Dereito: Revista xuridica da Universidade de Santiago de Compostela, ISSN 1132-9947, Vol. 28, Nº 2, 2019, págs. 117-161
• Idioma: español
• Títulos paralelos:
  • Legal analysis and critics of exception clauses between Rome I and II regulation and in other EU regulations
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo
• Resumen
  • español

    El presente trabajo se propone después de un examen preliminar necesario sobre la terminología y el nivel de clasificación para analizar las cláusulas en cuestión en virtud de la legislación de la UE y la jurisprudencia a nivel convencional. En esta reconstrucción será necesario identificar no solo el contenido y el alcance de los datos normativos, sino también comprender, en la medida de lo posible, con referencias prácticas, las hipótesis que pueden justificar y concretar concretamente la no aplicación de la regla de conflicto destinada a Funcionan en general, así como el uso de la cláusula de excepción.

  • English

    The present work is proposed after a necessary preliminary examination on the terminology and classification level to analyze the clauses in question under EU legislation and jurisprudence at a conventional level. In this reconstruction it will be necessary to identify not only the content and scope of the normative data but also to understand with examples where possible supported by practical references, the hypotheses that can concretely justify and concretize the non-application of the conflict rule destined to operate in general as well as the use of the exception clause.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • ABBASSI, A., BAZRPACH, H., “Distinction between exception clause and exemption clause”, in International Journal of Humanities and Cultural...
  • ADESINA OKOLI, C.S.A., “The significance of the doctrine of accessory allocation as a connecting factor under art. 4 on the Rome I Regulation”,...
  • ANCEL, M.E., “Les contrats de distribution et la nouvelle donne du règlement Rome I”, in Revue Critique de droit International Privè, 97,...
  • AUDIT, B., “A continental looks at contemporary american choice of law principles”, in American Journal of Comparative Law, 27 (4), 1979,...
  • AUDIT, B., Droit international privè, LGDJ, Paris, 2013, pp. 692ss.
  • BEHR, V., “Rome I Regulation. A-mostly-unified private international law of contractual relationship within most of the European Union”, in...
  • BENNETT, T.W., “Choice of law rules in claims of unjust enrichment”, in International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 39 (1), 1990, pp. 136ss.
  • BENTWICH, N., Westlake private international law, Sweet & Maxwell, London, 1925, pp. 212ss.
  • CUNIBERTI, G., MIGLIORINI, S., The European account preservation order Regulation. A commentary, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2018,...
  • DANOV, M., Jurisdictions and judgments in relation to EU competition claims, Hart Publishing, Oxford & Oregon, Portland, 2010, pp. 166ss.
  • DICKINSON, A., The Rome II Regulation. The law applicable to noncontractual obligations, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2008.
  • DIETZI, H., Zur Einführung einer generellen Ausweichklausel im schweizerischen IPR, in Festgabe zum Schweizerischen juristentag, Helbing &...
  • DROZ, G., “A comment on the role of the Hague conference on private international law”, in Law and Contemporary Problems, 57, 1994, pp. 5ss.
  • DUBLER, C.E., Les clauses d'exception en droit international privè. Etudes suisses de droit international, Genève, 35, 1983.
  • DUTTA, A., WURMNEST, W., European private international law and member state treaties with third states. The case of the European succession...
  • EINSELE, D., “Kapitelmarketrecht und Internationales Privatrecht”, in Rabels Zeitschrift für ausländisches und internationales Privatrecht,...
  • FERRARI, F., LEIBLE, S., Rome I Regulation. The law applicable to contractual obligations in Europe, European Law Publishers, The Hague, 2009,...
  • FOSTER, N., Foster on EU law, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2017.
  • GARCÍA GUTIÉRREZ, L., “Franchise contracts and the Rome I Regulation on the law applicable to international contracts”, in Yearbook of Private...
  • GONZALEZ CAMPOS, A., Diversification, spècialisation, flexibiliation et matèrialisation des règles de droit international privè, Cours gènèral,...
  • GROUSSOT, X., PETURSSON, G.T., “The EU Charter of the Fundamental Rights five years on. The emergence of a new constitutional framework?”,...
  • HATJE, A., TERHECHTE, J.P., MÜLLER-GRAFF, P.C., Europarechtswissenschaft, ed. Nomos, Baden-Baden, 2018.
  • HAY, P., “Unjust enrichment in the conflicts of law. A comparative view of german law and the american restatement”, in American Journal of...
  • HAY, P., Flexibility versus predictability and uniformity in choice of law: reflection on current European and United States conflicts law,...
  • HEY, P., Advanced introduction to private internatonal law and procedure, Edward Elgar Publishers, Cheltenham, 2018.
  • HIRSE, T., Die Ausweichklausel im Internationalen Privatrecht, Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen, 2006.
  • HOHLOCH, G., “Place of injury, habitual residency. Closer connections and substantive scope. The basic principles”, in The Yearbook of Private...
  • JAFFEY, A.J.E., “The english proper law doctrine and the EEC Convention”, in International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 33 (3), 1987, pp....
  • JAULT-SESEKE, F., Conflit de lois. Mise en oeuvre de la clause d'exception, in Recueil Dalloz, Paris, 2010, pp. 1586ss.
  • KNOEPFLER, F., Utilitè et danger d'une clause d'exception en droit international privè, in Hommage à Raumond jean prêtre, Neuchâtel,...
  • KREUZER, W., Berightigungsklauseln im internationalen privatrecht, in Festschrift für Imre Zajtay, Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen, 1982, pp. 296ss.
  • LAGARDE, P., “Remarques sur la proposition de règlement de la Commission europèenne sur la loi applicable aux obligations contractuelles (Rome...
  • LAGARDE, P., Le principe de proximitè dans le droit international privè contemporain. Cours gènèral de droit international privè, ed. Brill,...
  • LANDO, O., “New american choice of law principle and European conflict of laws of contracts”, in American and European Conflicts of Law, 30...
  • LIAKOPOULOS, D., Giustizia materiale nel diritto internazionale privato e comunitario, ed. Giuffrè, Milano, 2009.
  • MANGAS MARTÍN, A., Tratado de la Uniòn Europea, Tratado de Funcionamiento, ed. Marcial Pons, Madrid, 2018.
  • MARENGI, C., “The law applicable to product liability in context: article 5 of the Rome II Regulation and its interaction with other EU instruments”,...
  • MARIDAKIS, G.S., Le renoiv en droit international privè, ed. Brill, The Hague, 105, 1957, pp. 55ss.
  • MCPARLAND, M., The Rome I Regulation on the law applicable to contractual obligations, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2015.
  • MONATERI, P.G., Comparative contract law, Edward Elgar Publishers, Cheltenham, 2017, pp. 534ss.
  • MORRIS, J.H.C., “The proper law of the contract in the conflict of laws”, in Law Quarterly Review, 46, 1940, pp. 322ss.
  • MOSCONI, F., Exceptions to the operations of choice of law rules, in Recueil des cours, ed. Brill, The Hague, 217, 1989, pp. 189ss.
  • NADELMANN, K.H., “Choice of law resolved by rules or presumptions with an escape clause”, in American Journal of International Private Law,...
  • PALAO MORENO, G., ALONSO LANDETA, G., BUÍGUES, I., (dirs.), Sucesiones internacionales. Comentarios al Reglamento (UE) 650/2012, Marcial Pons,...
  • PATOCCHI, P.M., Règles de rattachement localisatrices et règles de rattachement à caractère substantiel, Geneve, 42, 1985.
  • PEERS S., et al. (eds.), The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights, A Commentary, Hart Publishing, Oxford & Oregon, Portland, 2014
  • ROBINSON, G., Optimize European Union law, ed. Routledge, London & New York, 2014.
  • ROSENTRITT, S., Die Gefahrtragung im europäischen und internationalen Kaufrecht, Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen, 2019.
  • SCHREIBER, S., Ausweichklauseln im deutschen, österreichischen und schweizerischen Internationalen Privatrecht, Kovac Verlag, Hamburg, 2001.
  • SCHWARZE, J., BECKER, V., HATJE, A., SCHOO, J., EU-Kommentar, ed. Nomos, Baden-Baden, 2019.
  • SIEHR, K., “General problem of private internatonal law in modern codification. De lege lata and de lege europea ferenda”, in Yearbook of...
  • STONE, P., EU Private international law, Edward Elgar Publishers, Cheltenahm, 2017, pp. 378ss.
  • STONE, P., FARAH, Y., Research Handbook on European Union private international law, Edward Elgar Publishers, Cheltenham, 2015.
  • SYMEONIDES, S.C., “Rome II and tort conflicts: a missed opportunity”, in American Journal of Comparative Law, 56, 2008, pp. 198ss.
  • SYMEONIDES, S.C., Choice of law, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2016.
  • SYMEONIDES, S.C., Codification and flexibility in private international law. General reports of the XVIIIth Congress of the international...
  • SYMEONIDES, S.C., Codifying choice of law around the world: an international comparative analysis, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2014.
  • VISCHÉR, F., “Das Problem der Kodifikation des schweizerischen internationalen Privatrechts”, in Zeitschrift für Schweizerische Recht, 90,...
  • VON OVERBECK, A.E., “De quelques règles gènèrales de conflits de lois dans les codification rècentes”, in J. BASEDOW (a cura di), Private...
  • VON OVERBECK, A.E., Les questions gènèrales du droit international privè à la lumioère des codifications et projects rècents, in Recueil des...
  • WIJCKMANS, F., TUYTSCHAEVER, F., Vertical agreements in EU competition law, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2011, pp. 14ss.
  • WILKE, F.M., A conceptual analysis of European private international law. The general issues in the EU and its member states, ed. Intersentia,...