Modena 1182, the origins of a new paradigm of ownership. The interface between historical contingency and the scholarly invention of legal categories

• Autores: Emanuele Conte
• Localización: Glossae: European Journal of Legal History, ISSN-e 2255-2707, ISSN 0214-669X, Nº 15, 2018, págs. 4-18
• Idioma: inglés
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo (pdf)
• Dialnet Métricas: 2 Citas
• Resumen

  • The legal phrase dominium utile is commonly known to express the property rights enjoyed by the person to whom a piece of land has been granted in fief or under other similar concessions. A considerable amount of legal-historical research has been spent on the origins, the reasons and effects of this legal concept, which proved to have played a very significant role in European history. One of the results of this historical research was that the first jurist who introduced the expression dominium utile was Pillius de Medicina, a law professor who moved from Bologna to the new born school of Modena in 1180. This article aims at an historical recontextualization of Pillius’ doctrinal construct in the frame of the political and social history of the city of Modena. However, this contingency of a doctrinal invention does not prevent a legal theory from transcend its particular circumstances to remain part of the tool-box which can be used by intellectuals in a completely different historical context, perhaps very remote from time and place of their first origins.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Anselminus de Orto, Super contractibus emphyteosis et precarii et libelli atque investiture (R. Jacobi, ed.), Weimar, 1854.
  • Belloni, A., Le questioni civilistiche del secolo XII: da Bulgaro a Pillio da Medicina, Frankfurt-am-Main, 1989.
  • Cammarosano, P. “La situazione economica del Regno d’Italia all’epoca di Federico Barbarossa”, Bullettino dell’Istituto Storico Italiano per...
  • Coing, H., “Zur Eigentumslehre des Bartolus”, Zeitschrift der Savigny-Stiftung für Rechtsgeschichte, Romanistische Abteilung 70 (1953), pp....
  • Conte, E.: “Droit médiéval. Un débat historiographique italien”, Annales. Histoire, Sciences sociales 57/6 (2002), pp. 1593-1613.
  • Conte, E.: “Res publica. Il modello antico, la politica e il diritto nel XII secolo”, Iuris Historia. Liber amicorum Gero Dolezalek (V. Colli...
  • Conte, E.: “Ordo iudicii et regula iuris: Bulgarus et les origines de la culture juridique (XIIème siècle)”, Frontières des savoirs en Italie...
  • Conte, E.: “Gewere, vestitura, spolium: un’ipotesi di interpretazione”, in Der Einfluss der Kanonistik auf die europäische Rechtskultur, Bd....
  • Cortese, E.: Il rinascimento giuridico medievale, 2nd revised edition, Rome, 1996.
  • Cortese, E.: “Controversie medievali sul dominio utile. Bartolo e il quidam doctor de Aurelianis, in Amicitiae pignus” [studies in honour...
  • Delbrück, B., Die dingliche Klage des deutschen Rechts, Leipzig ,1857.
  • Dizionario biografico degli italiani, Rome 2016.
  • Dizionario biografico dei giuristi italiani, Bologna, 2013.
  • Duynstee, M.C.I.M., L’enseignement du droit civil à l’université d’Orléans du début de la guerre des cent ans (1337) au siège de la ville...
  • Feenstra, R.: “Les origines du dominium utile chez les glossateurs (avec une appendice concernant l’opinion des ultramontani)”, originally...
  • Feenstra, R.: “Dominium and ius in re aliena: The Origins of a Civil Law Distinction”, first published in New Perspectives in the Roman Law...
  • Feenstra, R.: “Dominium utile est chimaera? Nouvelles réflexions sur le concept de propriété dans le droit savant (à propos d’un ouvrage récent)”,...
  • Giordanengo, G., “La féodalité”, La France médiévale (J. Favier, ed.), Paris, 1983, now in Giordanengo, G., Féodalités et droits savants dans...
  • Gouron, A., “La coutume en France au Moyen Age”, Recueils de la société Jean Bodin 52,2, La coutume, Bruxelles, 1990, pp. 193–217, now in...
  • Grossi, P., Locatio ad longum tempus. Locazione e rapporti reali di godimento nella problematica del diritto, Naples, 1963.
  • Grossi, P.: Le situazioni reali nell’esperienza giuridica medievale, Padova, 1968.
  • Grossi, P.: Il dominio e le cose. Percezioni medievali e moderne dei diritti reali, Milano, 1992.
  • Heirbaut, D., “Feudal Law: the Real Ius Commune of Property in Europe, or: Should We Reintroduce Duplex Dominium?”, European Private Law 3...
  • Heusler, A., Die Gewere, Weimar, 1872.
  • Meynial, E., “Notes sur la formation de la théorie du domaine divisé (domaine direct et domaine utile) du XIIe au XIVe siècle dans les romanistes....
  • Muratori, L.A., Antiquitates Italicae Medii Aevi, vol. III, diss. 36 (de emphyteusibus, precariis et laicorum decimis), coll. 149-156.
  • Phillips, G., Gründsätze des gemeinen deutschen Privatrechts mit Einschluss des Lehnrechts, I, Berlin, 1829.
  • Quinet, E., Les Révolutions d’Italie, Paris, 1848.
  • Registrum privilegiorum Comunis Mutinae, (L. Simeoni and E.P. Vicini, eds.), Reggio Emilia, 1940.
  • Reynolds, S.: Fiefs and Vassals. The Medieval Evidence Reinterpreted, Oxford, 1994.
  • Reynolds, S.: “Medieval Law”, The Medieval World (P. Linehan and J.L. Nelson, eds.), London – New York, 2001, pp. 484-502.
  • Rölker, R., Nobiltà e comune a Modena. Potere e amministrazione nei secoli XII e XIII, Modena, 1997 (updated Italian translation of the original...
  • Rota, A., “L’apparato di Pillio alle Consuetudines feudorum e il ms. 1004 dell’Arch. di Stato di Roma”, in St. e mem. per la storia dell’Univ....
  • Rüfner, Th., “The Roman Concept of Ownership and the Medieval Doctrine of Dominium Utile”, in The Creation of the Ius Commune : From Casus...
  • Statuta civitatis Mutine (anno 1327 reformata) (C. Campori, ed.), Mon. di storia patria delle provincie modenesi, serie degli statuti, I,...
  • Tiraboschi, G., Memorie storiche modenesi, Modena, 1793.