Clinical programs in community legal centres, the Australian approach

• Cody, Anna ^[1]
  1. [1] University of New South Wales
• Localización: Revista de educación y derecho = Education and law review, ISSN 2013-584X, ISSN-e 2386-4885, Nº. 4, 2011 (Ejemplar dedicado a: CLÍNICAS JURÍDICAS: DESAFÍO Y OPORTUNIDAD)
• Idioma: inglés
• Títulos paralelos:
  • Clinical programs in community legal centres, the Australian approach
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo (pdf)
• Resumen
  • español

    Este artículo ha analizado las ventajas de impartir cursos basados en la metodología jurídica clínica en un entorno como los centros jurídicos comunitarios. Estos cursos aportan a los estudiantes que trabajan con clientes en situación de desfavorecimiento o marginalidad, la oportunidad de observar las limitaciones de la ley a la hora de afrontar muchos problemas legales. Las Clínicas ubicadas en centros jurídicos comunitarios también enseñan la importancia de un enfoque de resolución de problemas a las complejas situaciones experimentadas por las comunidades en desventaja y la importancia del trabajo en equipo a la hora de hacerles frente. Las Clínicas en centros jurídicos comunitarios son idóneas asimismo para enseñar a los estudiantes cómo ejercer la abogacía de forma eficaz para las comunidades desfavorecidas enseñándoles habilidades específicas de reforma legislativa. Hay sin embargo desafíos sustanciales en la impartición de cursos clínicos en centros jurídicos comunitarios.

  • English

    This article argues that clinical programs situated within community legal centres can provide students with a rich learning experience. Drawing on a range of clinical course models, this article looks at the benefits of running clinics in community legal centres, including the opportunity for students to gain exposure to disadvantaged clients, engage in critical analysis of the legal system and the role of lawyers within it, and to develop skills in complex legal problem solving, collaborative team work, and law reform. Then, the limitations and challenges faced by combining clinical teaching with community legal centres are canvassed, including the skills demanded of students in work at community legal centres, such as high level emotional intelligence and casework skills, and the difficulties in doing effective law reform work. More specifically, the difficulty in balancing the urgency posed by individual client matters and the competing priority of addressing structural deficiencies in the law is discussed. The article posits that while clinics in community legal centres often struggle to achieve this balance, this should not preclude clinics from being based at community legal centres, but should rather be utilised as a basis for analysis of legal practice by students. The article concludes that while clinics situated in community legal centres face numerous challenges, the benefits of exposing students to community lawyering outweighs these limitations.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • AHMAD, M. (2007). Interpreting Communities: Lawyering Across Language Difference. UCLA Law Review, 54, 999-1086.
  • ASHAR, S.M. (2008). Law Clinics and Collective Mobilization. Clinical Law Review,14, 355-414.
  • BARTLETT, F., MORTENSEN, R. and TRANTER, K. (2011). Alternative perspectives on lawyers and legal ethics, re-imagining the profession. Abingdon:...
  • BELLOW, G. (1996). Steady work: A Practitioners Reflections on Political Lawyering. Harv C.R-C.L L Rev, 31, 297-309
  • BRODIE, J.M. (2009). Little Cases on the Middle Ground: Teaching Social Justice Lawyering in Neighborhood-Based Community Lawyering Clinics....
  • CODY, A. (July 2009) Yes we can: teaching students social justice. Paper presented at the 10th bi-annual Australian clinical legal education...
  • CODY, A. and GREEN, S. (2007). Clinical legal education and Indigenous legal education: what’s the connection? International Journal of Clinical...
  • CURRAN, L. (2004). Responsive Law Reform Initiatives by Students on Clinical Placement at La Trobe Law. Flinders Journal of Law Reform, 7(2),...
  • CURRAN, L. (2007). University Law Clinics and their value in undertaking client-centred law reform to provide a voice for clients’ experiences....
  • DICKSON, J. (2003). The Role of Clinic in Linking Law and Justice. Key note address at Australian Clinical Legal Education Conference. 11...
  • DICKSON, J. (2003). Teaching about Justice as well as Law. Alternative Law Journal, 28(1), 18-21.
  • DUBIN, J.C. (1998). Clinical design for social justice imperatives. SMU Law Review, 51. 1461-1505.
  • EVANS, A. (2005). A Interviewing. in Joanna Goldsworthy and Patricia Mowad (eds) Lawyers Practice Manual New South Wales. The Law Book Company...
  • EVANS, A. (2010). Assessing Lawyers’ Ethics. New York: Cambridge University Press
  • EVANS, A. and HYAMS, R.L. (2008). Independent Evaluations of Clinical Legal Eudcation Programs-Appropriate Objectives and Processes in an...
  • FREAMON, B.K. (1992). Blueprint for a Center for Social Justice. Seton Hall L Rev, 22, 1225-1249.
  • GIBSON, F. (2009). Paper presented to 10th bi-annual Clinical Legal Education Conference. Perth, July 2009.
  • GIDDINGS, J. (2003). Clinical Legal Education in Australia: A Historical Perspective. International Journal of Clinical Legal Education, 3(1),...
  • GIDDINGS, J. (2008). Contemplating the Future of Clinical Legal Education. Griffith Law Review, 17, 1-26.
  • LAUCHLAND, K.A. and LE BRUN, M.J. (1996). Legal Interview Theory, Tactics and Techniques. Sydney: Butterworths.
  • MC CRIMMON, L. (2004). Mandating a Culture of Service: Pro Bono in the Law School Curriculum. Legal Education Rev 1, 53-76; Legal Education...
  • MOSHER, J.E. (1997). Legal Education Nemesis or Ally of Social movements. Osgood Hall Journal, 35(3), 613-635
  • NOONE, M.A. (1997). ‘The Activist Origins of Australian CLCs’ in C. Arup & K. Laster (eds) For the Public Good: Pro Bono and the Legal...
  • ONG HING, B. (1993). Raising Personal Identification Issues of Class, Race, Ethnicity, Gender, Sexual Orientation, Physical disability and...
  • PARKER, C. and EVANS, D. (2007). Inside Lawyers Ethics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  • QUIGLEY, F. (1995). Seizing the disorienting moment: adult learning theory and the teaching of social justice in law school clinics. Clinical...
  • RAND, S. (2006). Teaching Law Students to Practice Social Justice: An Interdisciplinary Search for Help through Social Work's Empowerment...
  • RICH, N. (2009). Reclaiming Community Legal Centres: Maximising our potential so we can help our clients realise theirs. Victoria Law Foundation...
  • SANDEFUR, R.L. and SELBIN, J. (2009). The Clinic Effect. Clinical Law Review, 16, 57-107; New York Law School Clinical Research Institute...
  • TRANTER K. (2006). The Different side of Society, Street Practice and Australian Clinical Legal Education. Griffith Law Review. 15(1), 1-26.
  • VIVIAN, A. and COPELAND A. (2007). Human Rights as the Ordinary Work of Clinics. AltLaw Journal Monograph. 34(1).
  • WEXLER, S. (1970). Practicing Law for Poor People. Yale Law Journal, 79, 1049-1067.
  • WHITE, L. (1990). Subordination, Rhetorical Survival Skills and Sunday Shoes: Notes on the Hearing of Mrs G. Buffalo Law Review, 38, 1-58.
  • WIZNER, S. (2001). The social justice mission of clinical education: beyond skills training. Vol 7 Clinical Law Review 7, 327-340.
  • ZUNI CRUZ, C. (2006). Toward a Pedagogy and Ethic of Law/Lawyering for Indigenous Peoples. N.D. L. Rev. 82, 863-901.