Transitional Justice in Consultations of Hendrik van Kinschot (1541–1608) Learned Legal Practice on Wars, Loans and Credit

• Autores: Wouter Druwé
• Localización: Glossae: European Journal of Legal History, ISSN-e 2255-2707, ISSN 0214-669X, Nº 13, 2016, págs. 243-274
• Idioma: inglés
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo (pdf)
• Resumen

  • This article presents three consultations by Hendrik van Kinschot (Kinschotius, 1541- 1608), a lawyer from the Southern Netherlands who acted as an advocatus at the Council of Brabant. All three responsa deal with questions of loans and credit after a period of war and rebellion. Responsum 55 concerns a forced loan that had been accorded by the chapter of Saint Gudula in Brussels to the Calvinist-led magistrate in February 1580. After 1585, the chapter of Saint Gudula asked repayment. Questions on the liability of the new magistrate for contracts of its rebellious predecessors are raised and solved by our Brabantian jurist. Responsa 6 and 47 interpret restitution clauses in two peace treaties, namely the Pacification of Ghent (1576) and the Capitulation of Antwerp (1585). Especially the issue was raised whether the promised restitution also included claims against the fisc (nomina) that had been terminated through confusion (confusio). All three consultations offer a good example of learned legal practice.

    Kinschot skilfully applies the framework of the ius commune to the local situation, taking into account particular law.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Accursius, Glossa in Codicem, Venezia, 1488 (anastatic reprint: Juris Italici Historiae Instituto Taurinensis Universitatis, ex officina Erasmiana,...
  • Accursius, Glossa in Digestum Vetus, Venezia, 1488 (anastatic reprint: Juris Italici Historiae Instituto Taurinensis Universitatis, Mario...
  • Accursius, Glossa in Digestum Novum, Venezia, 1488 (anastatic reprint: Juris Italici Historiae Instituto Taurinensis Universitatis, Mario...
  • Anselmo, A., Placcaeten, Ordonnantien, Landt-charters, Blyde Incomsten, Privilegien, ende Instructien by de Princen van dese Neder-landen,...
  • Baldus de Ubaldis, Lectura super usibus feudorum: Commentum super Pace Constantiae, Prothasius Bozolus, Pavia, 1490.
  • Baldus de Ubaldis, Consiliorum, sive responsorum volumen primum, Venezia, 1575.
  • Baldus de Ubaldis, In primam Digesti Veteris partem Commentaria, Venezia, 1577.
  • Baldus de Ubaldis, In vii. viii. ix. x. et xi. Codicis libros Commentaria, Venezia, 1586.
  • Baldus de Ubaldis, In Primum, Secundum et Tertium Cod. Lib. Commentaria, Venezia, 1599.
  • Baldus de Ubaldis, In primam et secundam Infortiati partem Commentaria, Venezia, 1599.
  • Bartolus de Saxoferrato, In primam Digesti Veteris partem Commentaria, Turino, 1577.
  • Bartolus de Saxoferrato, In secundam Digesti Novi partem commentarius, Turino, 1577.
  • Bartolus de Saxoferrato, In secundam partem Digesti Veteris Commentaria, Basel, 1588.
  • Bossius, A., Tractatus varii qui omnem fere criminalem materiam excellenti doctrina complectuntur …, Lyon, apud haeredes Iacobi Iunctae, 1566.
  • Cacheranus, O., Decisiones Sacri Senatus Pedemontani, Lyon, 1579.
  • Christinaeus, P., Practicarum quaestionum rerumque in supremis Belgarum curiis actarum et observatarum decisiones, vol. 1, Antwerpen, ex officina...
  • Clarus, J., Opera omnia quae quidem hactenus per auctorem in lucem edita sunt, Frankfurt am Main, 1576.
  • Corneus, P. Ph., Consilia, Venezia, 1582.
  • Decius, Ph., Consiliorum sive responsorum, tomus II, Venezia, 1575.
  • Dinus Mugellanus, Tractatus super regulis iuris in Sexto, Paris, Iehan Petit, 1508.
  • Durand, G., Speculum iudiciale, Basel, 1574 (anastatic reprint: Scientia Verlag, Aalen, 1975).
  • Gaill, A., De pace publica et eius violatoribus, atque proscriptis sive bannitis imperii, Keulen, Johannes Gymnicus, 1586.
  • Gigans, H., Tractatus de crimine laesae maiestatis, Lyon, Sebastianus Bartolomaeus Honoratus, 1557.
  • Grotius, H., Van Groenewegen van der Made, S., and Schorrer, W., Inleiding tot de Hollandsche Rechtsgeleerdheid, Middelburg, by Pieter Gillissen,...
  • Gudelinus, P., De iure pacis commentarius, Köln, Johannes Busaeus, 1663.
  • Kinschotius, H., Responsa sive consilia iuris. Item de rescriptis gratiae a supremo senatu Brabantiae nomine Ducis concedi solitis, tractatus...
  • Kinschotius, H., De rescriptis gratiae a supremo Brabantiae senatu nomine Ducis concedi solitis tractatus VII, Leuven, apud Ioannem Oliverium...
  • Kinschotius, H., Responsa sive consilia juris, Brussel, Johannes Mommartii, 1653.
  • Jason de Mayno, Commentaria in secundam partem Digesti Veteris, Venezia, 1499.
  • Menochius, J., Consiliorum sive responsorum liber secundus, Frankfurt am Main, sumtibus Haeredum Andreae Wecheli et Ioan. Gymnici, 1594.
  • Negosantius, A., Tractatus de pignoribus et hypothecis, Köln, Constantinus Münich, 1656.
  • Nellus a Sancto Geminiano, Tractatus insignis de Bannitis, Lyon, haeredes Iacobi Giuntae, 1550.
  • Sande, J., Decisiones frisicae sive rerum in suprema Frisiorum curia iudicatarum libri 5, Leeuwarden, Johannes Jansonius, 1639.
  • Nicolaus de Tedeschis (Abbas Panormitanus), Commentaria in tertium Decretalium librum, tomus VI, Venezia, 1617.
  • Rufinus von Bologna (Magister Rufinus), Summa Decretorum (H. Singer, ed.), Aalen, Scientia Verlag, 1963.
  • Tiraquellus, A., Commentaria in utroque retractu et municipali et conventionali, Venezia, 1562.
  • Vervliet, D. (ed.), Articulen, ende Conditien vanden Tractate, aengegaen ende ghesloten tusschen de Hoocheyt vanden Prince van Parma, Plaisance,...
  • Wamesius, J., Responsorum sive consiliorum ad ius forumque civile pertinentium centuria tertia, Leuven, apud viduam Henrici Hastenii, 1631.
  • Wamesius, J., Responsorum sive consiliorum ad ius forumque civile pertinentium centuria quarta, Leuven, apud viduam Henrici Hastenii, 1632.
  • X., Sextus Liber Decretalium cum epitomis, divisionibus, et glossa ordinaria Domini Ioannis Andreae …, Lyon, apud Hugonem a Porta et Antonium...
  • Andreas, V., Bibliotheca Belgica: de Belgis vita scriptisque claris praemissa topographica Belgii totius seu Germaniae inferioris descriptione,...
  • Baelde, M., and van Peteghem, P., “De Pacificatie van Gent (1576)”, Opstand en Pacificatie in de Lage Landen. Bijdrage tot de studie van de...
  • Blom, J.C.H., and Lamberts, E., Geschiedenis van de Nederlanden, Uitgeversmaatschappij Agon, Amsterdam, 1994.
  • Cavina, M., “Consilia: il modello di Andrea Alciato. Tipologie formali e argomentative fra mos italicus e mos gallicus”, Clio@Themis....
  • Darby, G., “Narrative of Events”, The Origins and Development of the Dutch Revolt (G. Darby, ed.), Routledge, London/New York, 2001, pp. 8-28.
  • Decock, W., Theologians and Contract Law. The Moral Transformation of the Ius Commune (ca. 1500-1650) [Legal History Library 9 – Studies in...
  • Dondorp, H., “Decreeing Specific Performance: A (Roman-)Dutch Legacy”, Fundamina 16 (2010), pp. 40-51.
  • Falk, U., Consilia. Studien zur Praxis der Rechtsgutachten in der frühen Neuzeit, Frankfurt am Main, Vittorio Klostermann, 2006.
  • Feenstra, R., “Over de oorsprong van twee omstreden paragrafen uit de Inleidinge van Hugo de Groot (III.33.2 en III.34.2)”, Acta Juridica...
  • Henne, A., and Wauters, A., Histoire de la ville de Bruxelles, t. 1-2, Bruxelles, Libriarie encyclopédique de Périchon, 1845.
  • Lesaffer, R., “An Early Treatise on Peace Treaties: Petrus Gudelinus Between Roman Law and Modern Practice”, Journal of Legal History 23/3...
  • Marnef, G., “Het protestantisme te Brussel onder de ‘calvinistische Republiek’, ca. 1577-1585”, Etat et Religion aux XVe et XVIe siècles /...
  • Maturantius, F., “Vita Petri Philippi Cornei Perusini”, Virorum qui superiori nostroque seculo eruditione et doctrina illustres atque memorabiles...
  • Mehr, R., Societas und universitas. Römischrechtliche Institute im Unternehmensgesellschaftsrecht vor 1800 [Forschungen zur Neueren Privatrechtsgeschichte],...
  • Nauwelaers, J., Histoire des avocats au souverain Conseil de Brabant, t. II, Bruxelles, Bruylant, 1947.
  • Rainer, M., “Zum ius postliminii an Sachen im Register Innozenz’ III”, Zeitschrift der Savigny-Stiftung für Rechtsgeschichte. Romanistische...
  • Rossi, G., “Teoria e prassi nel maturo diritto comune: la giurisprudenza consulente nel pensiero di Tiberio Deciani”, Tiberio Deciani (1509-1592)...
  • Rowan, S., “Ist die Veröffentlichung von Konsilien Vertrauensbruch? Eine Diskussion innerhalb des Juristenstandes im ersten Jahrhundert des...
  • Geburtstag. Rechtsgeschichte mit internationaler Perspektive (G. Kohl, C. Neschwara and T. Simon, eds.), Wien, Manzsche Verlags- und Universitätsbuchhandlung,...
  • Van der Wee, H., and Materné, J., “De Antwerpse wereldmarkt tijdens de 16de en 17de eeuw”, Antwerpen, verhaal van een metropool. 16de-17de...
  • Vermeir, R., “Pieter (Pierre) Roose”, http://www.dutchrevolt.leiden.edu/dutch/personen/R/Pages/roose.aspx (last consultation: 15 April 2016).
  • Waelkens, L., Amne adverso. Roman Legal Heritage in European Culture, Leuven, Leuven University Press, 2015.
  • Waelkens, L., “La cause de D. 44,4,2,3”, Tijdschrift voor Rechtsgeschiedenis 75 (2007), pp. 199-212.
  • Wagner, U., “Niederlande”, Handbuch der Quellen und Literatur der neueren europäischen Privatrechtsgeschichte, II, Gesetzgebung und Rechtsprechung...
  • Wieacker, F., Privatrechtsgeschichte der Neuzeit: unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der deutschen Entwicklung, Göttingen, Vandenhoeck und...
  • Wijffels, A., “Business Relations between Merchants in Sixteenth-Century Belgian Practice-Orientated Civil Law Literature”, From lex mercatoria...
  • X., Seconde partie du catalogue des livres et manuscrits rares et précieux, de la bibliothèque de feu M.r. Pierre-Philippe-Constant Lammens,...
  • X., “De tekst van de Pacificatie van Gent met begeleidende documenten”, Opstand en Pacificatie in de Lage Landen. Bijdrage tot de studie van...