A Tax Can Increase Profit of a Monopolist or a Monopoly-like Firm: a Fiction or Distinct Possibility?

• Chin W. Yang ^[1] ; Hui Wen Cheng ^[2] ; Ching Wen Chi ^[2] ; Bwo-Nung Huang ^{[3] [4]}
  1. [1] Clarion University

     Clarion University

     Borough of Clarion, Estados Unidos

     
  2. [2] Ming Chuan University

     Ming Chuan University

     Taoyuan District, Taiwán

     
  3. [3] National Chung Cheng University

     National Chung Cheng University

     W. District, Taiwán

     
  4. [4] National Chin-Yi University of Technology

     National Chin-Yi University of Technology

     Taiwán

     

  Mostrar afiliaciones +
• Localización: Hacienda Pública Española / Review of Public Economics, ISSN 0210-1173, Nº 216, 2016, págs. 39-60
• Idioma: inglés
• DOI: 10.7866/hpe-rpe.16.1.2
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo (pdf)
• Resumen

  • The purpose of this paper is to reexamine the long-held theory that a tax reduces profit under monopoly or monopoly-like market structure. To present the paradox, we expand the switching price elasticity theory developed by Greenhut-Hwang-Ohta to show that the after-tax profit may very well increase in a monopoly or a tight-knit cartel. The result show that after-tax profit can actually increase in a monopoly or monopoly-like market without resorting to conjectural variation or product quality often used in oligopoly. To verify the paradox, simple numerical examples and commonly-used mathematical demand functions are employed.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Alm, J., Sennoga, E. and Skidmore, M. (2009), «Perfect competition, urbanization, and tax incidence in the retail gasoline market», Economic...
  • Arthur D. Little Inc. (2000), «Public finance balance of smoking in the Czech Republic», Philip Morris. Bate(s) number: 2085293756/2085293783,...
  • Baltagi, B. H., Griffm, J. M., and Xiong, W. (2000), «To pool or not to pool: Homogeneous versus heterogeneous estimators applied to cigarette...
  • Beckman, S. R. and Smith, W. J. (1993), «Positively sloping marginal revenue, CES utility and subsistence requirements», Southern Economic...
  • Bello, A. and Contin-Pilart, I. (2012), «Taxes, cost and demand shifters as determinants in the regional gasoline price formation process:...
  • Benowitz, N. L. and Henningfield, J. E. (2013), «Reducing the nicotine content to make cigarettes less addictive», Tobacco Control, 22 (Suppl...
  • Besley, T. and Suzumura, K. (1992), «Taxation and welfare in an oligopoly with strategic com-mitment», International Economic Review, 33(2):...
  • Bihari, S. and Seldon, B. J. (2006), «The effect of government advertising policies on the market power of cigarette firms», Review of Industrial...
  • Bodoni, S. (2013), «Siemens, Toshiba, Mitsubishi lose Cartel appeal at EU top court», December 19, 2013, available from «BloombergBusiness»...
  • Bonnet, C. and Requillart, V. (2013), «Impact of cost shocks on consumer prices in vertically-related markets: The case of the French soft...
  • Buchanan, J. M. (1969), «External diseconomies, corrective taxes, and market structure», American Economic Review, 59(1): 174-177.
  • Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids (2014), «Broken promises to our children: A state-by-state look at the 1998 State Tobacco Settlement 16 years...
  • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2014), available from http://apps.nccd.cdc.gov/statesys-tem/Default/Default.aspx, accessed at...
  • Coats, R. M. (1995), «A note on estimating cross- border effects of state cigarette taxes», National Tax Journal, 48: 573-584.
  • Coughlin, P. J. (1984), «Changes in marginal revenue and related elasticities», Southern Economic Journal, 51(2): 568-573.
  • Delipalla, S. and Keen, M. (1992), «The comparison between ad valorem and special taxation under imperfect competition», Journal of Public...
  • Fowler, S. J. and Ford, W. F. (2004), «Has a Quarter-Trillion-Dollar Settlement helped the tobacco industry?» Journal of Economics and Finance,...
  • Fullerton, D. and Metcalf, G. E. (2002), «Tax incidence», Handbook of Public Economics, 1787-1872.
  • Goering, G. E. and Boyce, J. R. (1996), «Taxation and market power when products are durable», Journal of Regulatory Economics, 9: 83-94.
  • Greenhut, M. L., Hwang, M. J., and H. Ohta (1974), «Price discrimination by regulated motor carriers: Comment», The American Economic Review,...
  • Greenhut, M. L. and Ohta, H. (1975), Theory of spatial pricing and market areas, Durham: Duke University Press.
  • Griffin, J. M. and Teece, D. J. (1982), OPEC behavior and world oil prices, London: George Allen & Unwin.
  • Hamilton, J. L. (1972), «The demand for cigarettes: Advertising, the health scare, and the cigarette advertising ban», The Review of Economics...
  • Harris, J. E. (1987), «The 1983 increase in the federal cigarette excise tax», In Tax Policy and the Economy, 1, edited by Lawrence, H., 87-112,...
  • Jampel, S. (2013), «What a pack of cigarettes costs now, state by state», July 12, 2013, available from «The AWL», http://www.theawl.com/2013/07/what-a-pack-of-cigarettes-costs-now-state-by-state,...
  • Katz, M. I. and Rosen, H. S. (1985), «Tax analysis in an oligopoly model», Public Finance Quarterly, 13: 3-20.
  • Keeler, T. E., Hu, T. W., Manning, W. G., and Sung, H. (2001), «State tobacco taxation, education and smoking: Controlling for the effect...
  • Krzyzaniak, M. and Musgrave, R. A. (1963), The shifting of the corporate income tax, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
  • LINGO (2002), The modeling language and optimizer, Chicago: LINDO System Inc.
  • Lorillard Inc. (2014), «2013 Annual report», 1-129, available from «Lorillard», http://investors.lori-llard.com/investor-relations/financialreporting/default.aspx,...
  • Musgrave, R. A. (1959), The theory of public finance: A study in public economy, New York: McGraw-Hill.
  • Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) (2014), «Annual report 2013», available from «Organization of the Petroleum Exporting...
  • Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) (2015), «OPEC monthly oil market report», January 15, 2015, available from «Organization...
  • Orzechowski, W. and Walker, R. (2013), «The tax burden on tobacco», Historical Compilation, 48: 1-360, available from «Federation of Tax Administrators»,...
  • Philip Morris International (2012), «2012 Philip Morris International Inc. annual report», available from «Philip Morris International», http://investors.pmi.com/phoenix.zhtml?c=146476&p=irol-reportsannual,...
  • Politi, R. B. and Mattos, E. (2011), «Ad-valorem tax incidence and after-tax price adjustments: Evidence from Brazilian basic basket food»,...
  • Primont, D. F. and Primont, D. (1995), «Further evidence of positively sloping marginal revenue curves», Southern Economic Journal, 62(2):...
  • Reynolds American Inc. (2012), «Form 10-K: Annual report», February 15, 2012, 1-192, available from «RAI- Reynolds American», http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/RAI/3778125900x0xS1193125-12-62917/1275283/filing.pdf,...
  • Reynolds American Inc. (2013), «Form 10-K: Annual report», February 12, 2013, 1-175, available from «RAI- Reynolds American», http://www.reynoldsamerican.com/secfiling.cfm?filingID=1193125-13-50521,...
  • Reynolds American Inc. (2014), «Form 10-K: Annual report», February 11, 2014, 1-184, available from «RAI- Reynolds American», http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/RAI/3778125900x0xS1193125-14-44598/1275283/filing.pdf,...
  • Roberts, L. (2015), «Missouri ranks among lowest in US for tobacco prevention spending», January 15, 2015, available from «KTTS», http://www.jrn.com/ktts/news/Missouri-Ranks-Among-Lowest-In-US-For-Tobacco-Prevention-Spending-288750471.html,...
  • Rosen, H. S and Gayer, T. (2008), Public finance, 8th edition, New York: McGraw-Hill.
  • Seade, J. (1985), «Profitable cost increases and the shifting of taxation: Equilibrium response of markets in oligopoly», The Warwick Economics...
  • Shirane, R., Smith, K., Ross, H., Silver, K. E., Williams, S., and Gilmore, A. (2012), «Tobacco industry manipulation of tobacco excise and...
  • Solow, J. L. (2001), «Exorcising the ghost of cigarette advertising past: Collusion, regulation, and fear advertising», Journal of Macro marketing,...
  • Suits, D. B. and Musgrave, R. A. (1953), «Ad valorem and unit taxes compared», Quarterly Journal of Economics, 7: 598-604.
  • Thursby, J. G. and Thursby, M. C. (2000), «Interstate cigarette bootlegging: Extent, revenue losses, and effects of federal intervention»,...
  • Tobacco Reporter (2015), «Company team building hit by cigarette price hike», January 28, 2015, available from http://www.tobaccoreporter.com/2015/01/company-team-building-hit-by-cigarette-price-hike/,...
  • World Health Organization (2010), «WHO technical manual on tobacco tax administration», available from «World Health Organization», http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publications/2010/9789241563994_eng.pdf,...
  • Yang, C. W., Harley, C. B., Huang, B. N., and Hwang, M. J. (2011a), «A monopolist can never price in the inelastic range of a demand curve...
  • Yang, C. W., Hwang, M. J., and Huang, B. N. (2002), «An analysis of factors affecting price volatility of the U. S. oil market», Energy Economics,...
  • Yang, C. W., Trumbull, W. N. Cushing, B. J., and Hwang, M. J. (2011b), «Do price increases while demand is falling indicate collusion?» Journal...
  • Yurekli, A. A. and Zhang, P. (2000), «The impact of clean indoor-air laws and cigarette smuggling on demand for cigarettes: An empirical model»,...