Publishing a book chapter in an edited collection carries a perception that doing so is akin to “burying” one’s work. This research investigates whether book chapters from edited collections within the field of library and information science suffer from discovery challenges in three indexing databases: Google Scholar, Web of Science Book Citation Index (BKCI), and Dimensions. Findings show a consistent lack of comprehensive indexing across all three indices. This research also sought to answer questions about open access and book chapters; due to the lack of discoverability of half of the book chapters, however, these questions could not be addressed. The results highlight concerns about the discoverability of book chapters within edited collections, particularly in the field of library and information science, while also examining potential avenues to increase discovery