A Response to Four Critics of The Long Arc of Legality

• David Dyzenhaus ^[1]
  1. [1] University of Toronto

     University of Toronto

     Canadá

     
• Localización: Analisi e diritto = Análisis y derecho = Law and analysis = Droit et analyse = Análise e direito, ISSN 1126-5779, ISSN-e 2785-7220, Vol. 24, Nº. 2 (Publicado: 21-01-2025), 2024, págs. 177-188
• Idioma: varios idiomas
• DOI: 10.4454/a0re8067
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Resumen

  • The four participants in the panel on my book offered very different critiques, so I responded to them separately. But, as will be clear from my responses, I have learned from all of them much about not only the arguments I made which attracted their criticism, but also about how to take forward those arguments in my future work. My first response to Luca Malagoli focuses on how best to interpret Hobbes. My responses to both Brian Bix and Giovanni Battista Ratti relate mainly to differences in methodology. Finally, I respond to Alejandro Daniel Calzetta’s challenge based on the problem of unjust law.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Alchourr6n, C.E., Bulygin, E. (1971). Normative Systems, New York, Springer Verlag.
  • Bix, B. (2025) Legalzty as Such: Further Thoughts on David Dyzenhaus, The Long Are of Legality, in this volume.
  • Bobbio, N. (1993 ). Thomas Hobbes and the Natural Law Tradition (Trans~ation by Daniela Gobetti of N. Bobbio, Thomas Hobbes e il diritto naturale,...
  • Bobbio, N. (1993a). Natural Law and Civzl Law in the Political Philosophy o/Thomas Hobbes, in id., 114-148.
  • Bobbio, N. (1993b). Introduction to De Cive, in Id., 74-113,
  • Bobbio, N. (2025a). Aspects of Lega! Positivism. (Translation by Giovanni Battista Ratti of "Sul positivismo giuridico" in (1961)...
  • Bobbio, N. (2025b). On Secondary Rules. (Translation by Giovanni Battista Ratti of Per un lessico di teoria generale del diritto, in Studi...
  • Calzetta, A.D. (2025). Once More unto the Breach, Dear Friends, Once More. The Puzzle o/ Unjust Law between Theoretical and Practical Realities:...
  • Dyzenhaus, D. (2021). Thomas Hobbes and tbe Rule by Law Tradition, in J. Meierhenrich, M. Loughlin (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to the...
  • Dyzenhaus, D. (2022), The Long Are o/ Legality. Hobbes, Kelsen, Hart, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
  • Dyzenhaus, D. (2025), Norberto Bobbio and HLA Hart: An Introduction, «Jurisprudence », forthcoming.
  • Fuller, L.L. (1969). The Morality of Law, New Haven, Yale University Press.
  • Hart, H.L.A. (1982). Essays on Bentham: Jurisprudence and Politica! Tbeory, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
  • Hart, H.L.A. ( 1983). Jhering' s Heaven o/ Concepts and Modern Analytical Jurisprudence, in Id., Essays in [urisprudence and Pbilosopby,...
  • Hobbes, Th. (1998). De Cive (the English Version, 1651, Latin Version 1642), edited and introduced by Richard Tuck and Michael Silverthorne,...
  • Hobbes, Th. (1994). Leviathan (1651), edited and introduced by Edwin Curley, Indianapolis, Hackett.
  • Kramer, M. (1999). In Defense of Lega! Positivism, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
  • Malagoli, L. (2025). A Tale of Two Hobbes: Brief Remarks (through Turinese eyes) on the Second Chapter o/ David Dyzenbaus, The Long Are o/...
  • Nagel, T. (2023). Analytic Philosophy and Human Life, New York, Oxford University Press.
  • Ratti, G.B. (2025): Three Puzzles on the Foundations of Law, in this volume.
  • Raz J. (1970). The Concept of a Lega! System, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
  • Raz, J. ( 1983). Legitimate Authority, in Id., The Authority of Law: Essays on Law and Morality, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 3-33.