Governments and parliaments in a state of emergency: what can we learn from the COVID-19 pandemic?

• Francesco Bromo ^[1] ; Paolo Gambacciani ^[2] ; Marco Improta ^[3]
  1. [1] Texas A&M University

     Texas A&M University

     Estados Unidos

     
  2. [2] University of Bologna

     University of Bologna

     Bolonia, Italia

     
  3. [3] Università degli Studi di Siena

     Università degli Studi di Siena

     Siena, Italia

     

  Mostrar afiliaciones +
• Localización: The Journal of legislative studies, ISSN 1357-2334, Vol. 31, Nº. 4, 2025, págs. 918-946
• Idioma: inglés
• DOI: 10.1080/13572334.2024.2313310
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Resumen

  • What happens in a state of emergency that is prolonged and unrelated to security with respect to the powers afforded to or used by the executive, checks and balances, and cooperation between the government, parliament, and sub-national authorities? This article investigates the variation in ‘executive aggrandisement’ (a temporary reduction in influence and oversight capacity of formal institutions vis-à-vis the executive) during the COVID-19 pandemic in six parliamentary democracies. We theorise that this variation can be in part explained based on path dependence. We explore how pre-pandemic levels of executive dominance and policy centralisation affect executive aggrandisement during the 2020–2022 emergency across our sample of countries. We show that Canada and Germany experienced little to no aggrandisement. In France, Israel, Italy, and the United Kingdom, government rule increased throughout the crisis at the expense of parliament and sub-national authorities. In line with our expectations, we find that most facets of the process of executive aggrandisement in a state of emergency can be interpreted in view of prior institutional arrangements. The outlier elements can be explained by considering circumstantial factors. Our evidence contributes to the literature on the political consequences of COVID-19 by filling some gaps regarding the roots of executive aggrandisement.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Albin, E., Bar-Siman-Tov, I., Gross, A., & Hostovsky-Brandes, T. (2021). Israel: Legal response to Covid-19. In J. King, & O. Ferraz...
  • Allweil, Y. (2022). Resisting COVID-19 authoritarianism. In N. Koch (Ed.), Spatializing authoritarianism (pp. 356–381). Syracuse University...
  • Altiparmakis, A., Bojar, A., Brouard, S., Foucault, M., Kriesi, H., & Nadeau, R. (2021). Pandemic politics: Policy evaluations of government...
  • Anderson, P. (2021). The Covid-19 pandemic in the United Kingdom. In N. Steytler (Ed.), Comparative federalism and Covid-19 (pp. 142–159)....
  • Baldwin, N. D. J. (2004). Concluding observations: Legislative weakness, scrutinising strength? The Journal of Legislative Studies, 10(2-3),...
  • Bandelow, N. C., Hassenteufel, P., & Hornung, J. (2021). Patterns of democracy matter in the COVID-19 crisis: A comparison of French and...
  • Bar-Siman-Tov, I. (2020). Covid-19 meets politics: The novel coronavirus as a novel challenge for legislatures. The Theory and Practice of...
  • Bar-Siman-Tov, I., Cohen, I., & Koth, C. (2021). The changing role of judicial review during prolonged emergencies: The Israeli Supreme...
  • Becher, M., Brouard, S., & Stegmueller, D. (2023). Endogenous benchmarking and Government accountability: Experimental evidence from the...
  • Benamouzig, D. (2022). France: From decentralisation to defiance? In K. Lynggaard, M. D. Jensen, & M. Kluth (Eds.), Governments’ responses...
  • Bermeo, N. (2016). On democratic backsliding. Journal of Democracy, 27(1), 5–19. https://doi.org/10.1353/jod.2016.0012
  • Bolleyer, N., & Salát, O. (2021). Parliaments in times of crisis: COVID-19, populism and executive dominance. West European Politics,...
  • Bromo, F., Gambacciani, P., & Improta, M. (2023). Executive power and accountability in Italy and the Government’s response to Covid-19....
  • Broschek, J. (2022). Federalism, political leadership and the Covid-19 Pandemic: Explaining Canada’s tale of two federations. Territory, Politics,...
  • Bull, M. (2021). The Italian Government response to Covid-19 and the making of a Prime Minister. Contemporary Italian Politics, 13(2), 149–165....
  • Capano, G., Howlett, M., Jarvis, D. S. L., Ramesh, M., & Goyal, N. (2020). Mobilizing policy (in)capacity to fight COVID-19: Understanding...
  • Chambas, E., & Perroud, T. (2021). France: Legal Response to Covid-19. In J. King, O. Ferraz, P. Villarreal, A. Jones, A. Bogg, N. Countouris,...
  • Cheibub, J. A., Hong, J.-Y., & Przeworski, A. (2020). Rights and deaths: Government reactions to the pandemic. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3645410.
  • Civitarese Matteucci, S., Pioggia, A., Repetto, G., Tega, D., Pignataro, M., Celepija, M., Ferrara, L., Piazza, I., & Cavasino, E. (2021)....
  • Cormacain, R. (2020). Keeping Covid-19 emergency legislation socially distant from ordinary legislation: Principles for the structure of emergency...
  • Cox, G. W., & Weingast, B. R. (2018). Executive constraint, political stability, and economic growth. Comparative Political Studies, 51(3),...
  • Derosier, J.-P., & Toulemonde, G. (2020). The French Parliament in the time of Covid-19: Parliament on life support. Robert Schuman Foundation....
  • Diamond, P., & Laffin, M. (2022). The United Kingdom and the Pandemic: Problems of central control and coordination. Local Government...
  • Dowding, K. (2013). The Prime ministerialisation of the British Prime Minister. Parliamentary Affairs, 66(3), 617–635. https://doi.org/10.1093/pa/gss007
  • du Boys, C., Bertolucci, M., & Fouchet, R. (2022). French inter-governmental relations during the Covid-19 Crisis: Between hyper-centralism...
  • Engler, S., Brunner, P., Loviat, R., Abou-Chadi, T., Leemann, L., Glaser, A., & Kübler, D. (2021). Democracy in times of the pandemic:...
  • Flood, C., & Thomas, B. (2021). Canada: Legal response to Covid-19. In J. King, O. Ferraz, P. Villarreal, A. Jones, A. Bogg, N. Countouris,...
  • Gidengil, E., Stolle, D., & Bergeron-Boutin, O. (2022). COVID-19 and support for executive aggrandizement. Canadian Journal of Political...
  • Ginsburg, T., & Versteeg, M. (2021). The bound executive: Emergency powers during the pandemic. International Journal of Constitutional...
  • Goetz, K. H., & Martinsen, D. S. (2021). COVID-19: A dual challenge to European liberal democracy. West European Politics, 44(5-6), 1003–1024....
  • Guasti, P. (2021). Democratic erosion and democratic resilience in Central Europe during COVID-19. Czech Journal of International Relations,...
  • Guasti, P., & Bustikova, L. (2022). Pandemic power grab. East European Politics, 38 (4), 529–550. https://doi.org/10.1080/21599165.2022.2122049
  • Hassenteufel, P. (2020). Handling the COVID-19 crisis in France: Paradoxes of a centralized state-led health system European Policy Analysis,...
  • Hegele, Y., & Schnabel, J. (2021). Federalism and the management of the COVID-19 Crisis: Centralisation, decentralisation and (non-)coordination....
  • Hitman, G., & Serpa, S. (2021). More divided than united: Israeli social protest during Covid-19 pandemic of 2020. Cogent Social Sciences,...
  • Horne, A., & Torrance, M. (2023). Parliament as scrutineer: Parliamentary oversight of the law-making process. In C. Harlow (Ed.), A Research...
  • Kaiser, A.-B., & Hensel, R. (2021). Federal Republic of Germany: Legal response to Covid-19. In J. King, O. Ferraz, P. Villarreal, A....
  • Khaitan, T. (2019). Executive aggrandizement in established democracies: A crisis of liberal democratic constitutionalism. International Journal...
  • Khaitan, T. (2020). Killing a Constitution with a Thousand Cuts: Executive Aggrandizement and Party-state Fusion in India. Law & Ethics...
  • King, J., & Byrom, N. (2021). United Kingdom: Legal response to Covid-19. In J. King, O. Ferraz, P. Villarreal, A. Jones, A. Bogg, N....
  • Kropp, S., & Schnabel, J. (2021). Germany’s response to COVID-19. In R. Chattopadhyay, J. Light, F. Knüpling, D. Chebenova, L. Whittington,...
  • Kuhlmann, S., & Franzke, J. (2022). Multi-level responses to COVID-19: Crisis coordination in Germany from an intergovernmental perspective....
  • Kuhlmann, S., Hellström, M., Ramberg, U., & Reiter, R. (2021). Tracing divergence in crisis governance: Responses to the COVID-19 pandemic...
  • Kuhn, K., & Morlino, I. (2022). Decentralisation in times of crisis: Asset or liability? The case of Germany and Italy during Covid-19....
  • Lecours, A., Béland, D., Fenna, A., Fenwick, T. B., Paquet, M., Rocco, P., & Waddan, A. (2021). Explaining intergovernmental conflict...
  • Lijphart, A. (1984). Democracies: Patterns of majoritarian and consensus government in twenty-one countries. Yale University Press.
  • Lowande, K., & Rogowski, J. C. (2021). Executive power in crisis. American Political Science Review, 115(4), 1406–1423. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055421000447
  • Lührmann, A., Marquardt, K. L., & Mechkova, V. (2020). Constraining governments: New indices of vertical, horizontal, and diagonal accountability....
  • Lupo, N. (2019). «Legislative populism?»: Continuity and discontinuity in trends of Italian legislation. Ragion Pratica, 1/2019, 251–272.
  • Lupo, N., & Piccirilli, G. (2021). Omnibus legislation and maxi-amendments in Italy: How to circumvent the constitutional provision requiring...
  • Mahler, G. (2018). The “constitutional” system of Israel. In R. Y. Hazan, A. Dowty, M. Hofnung, & G. Rahat (Eds.), The Oxford handbook...
  • Maor, M., Sulitzeanu-Kenan, R., & Chinitz, D. (2020). When COVID-19, constitutional crisis, and political deadlock meet: The Israeli case...
  • Marchetti, G. (2021). The management of the coronavirus emergency by the Italian government and the relationship between state and regions....
  • Norton, P. (1990). Parliaments: A framework for analysis. West European Politics, 13 (3), 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1080/01402389008424803
  • O’Donnell, G. A. (1994). Delegative democracy. Journal of Democracy, 5(1), 55–69. https://doi.org/10.1353/jod.1994.0010
  • Paquet, M., & Schertzer, R. (2020). COVID-19 as a complex intergovernmental problem. Canadian Journal of Political Science, 53(2), 343–347....
  • Petrov, J. (2020). The COVID-19 emergency in the age of executive aggrandizement: What role for legislative and judicial checks? The Theory...
  • Pignataro, M. (2022). Constitutional degradation in a time of coronavirus: Reflecting on governmental accountability in the United Kingdom...
  • Platon, S. (2020). Reinventing the wheel … and rolling over fundamental freedoms? The Covid-19 epidemic in France and the ‘state of health...
  • Poguntke, T., & Webb, P. (2005). The presidentialization of politics in democratic societies: A framework for analysis. In T. Poguntke...
  • Rahat, G. (2018). Political Reform in Israel. In R. Y. Hazan, A. Dowty, M. Hofnung, & G. Rahat (Eds.), In The Oxford Handbook of Israeli...
  • Rayment, E., & VandenBeukel, J. (2020). Pandemic parliaments: Canadian legislatures in a time of crisis. Canadian Journal of Political...
  • Rhodes, R. A. W. (1994). The hollowing out of the state: The changing nature of the public service in Britain. The Political Quarterly, 65(2),...
  • Roland, G. (2004). Understanding institutional change: Fast-moving and slow- moving institutions. Studies in Comparative International Development,...
  • Roussellier, N. (2018). France and the fifth republic. Constitutional crisis or political malaise? In M. A. Graber, S. Levinson, & M....
  • Rullo, L. (2021). The COVID-19 pandemic crisis and the personalization of the government in Italy. International Journal of Public Leadership,...
  • Schnabel, J., & Hegele, Y. (2021). Explaining intergovernmental coordination during the COVID-19 pandemic: Responses in Australia, Canada,...
  • Segatto, C. I., Béland, D., & Dinan, S. (2021). Canadian Federalism in the Pandemic. In B. Guy Peters, E. Grin, & F. L. Abrucio (Eds.),...
  • Siaroff, A. (2003). Varieties of parliamentarianism in the advanced industrial democracies International Political Science Review, 24(4),...
  • Sieberer, U. (2011). The institutional power of western European parliaments: A multidimensional analysis. West European Politics, 34(4),...
  • Simonsen, S. (2022). Swedish exceptionalism and the Sars-CoV2 pandemic crisis: Representations of crisis and national identity in the public...
  • Thiers, C., & Wehner, L. (2023). Britain’s COVID-19 battle: The role of political leaders in shaping the responses to the pandemic. The...
  • Tsebelis, G. (2002). Veto players: How political institutions work. Princeton University Press.
  • Tsebelis, G. (2009). Agenda setting and executive dominance in politics. In S. Ganghof, C. Hönnige, & C. Stecker (Eds.), Parlamente, Agendasetzung...
  • Vampa, D. (2021). COVID-19 and territorial policy dynamics in Western Europe: Comparing France, Spain, Italy, Germany, and the United Kingdom....
  • Vedaschi, A. (2022). The marginalisation of parliament in facing the coronavirus emergency: What about democracy in Italy? In M. C. Kettemann...