The Step into Existence: Reasoning toward God in Mendelssohn’s Morning Hours

• Sánchez de León Serrano, José María ^[1]
  1. [1] Universitat de Barcelona

     Universitat de Barcelona

     Barcelona, España

     
• Localización: Con-textos Kantianos: International Journal of Philosophy, ISSN-e 2386-7655, Vol. 22, 2025, págs. 67-78
• Idioma: inglés
• DOI: 10.5209/kant.104302
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo (pdf)
• Resumen

  • This article offers a detailed analysis of Moses Mendelssohn’s novel proof of God’s existence as developed in chapter 16 of his philosophical testament, Morning Hours. The paper reconstructs the logical structure of the argument, situates it within Mendelssohn’s broader philosophical outlook, and explores its far-reaching implications. It also investigates the possible historical sources and conceptual affinities of the argument. While some scholars have read Mendelssohn’s argument as a version of Berkeleyan idealism, others highlight its cosmological or anti-idealist dimensions. The article concludes by assessing the philosophical significance and limits of Mendelssohn’s approach, arguing that it offers a compelling, if ultimately contestable, attempt to reconcile finite cognition with metaphysical realism through the postulation of an infinite intellect.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Alquié, F. (1974), Le cartésianisme de Malebranche, Vrin, Paris.
  • Altmann, A. (1982), “Moses Mendelssohn’s Proofs for the Existence of God”, in Die Trostvolle Aufklärung. Studien zur Metaphysik und Politischen...
  • Altmann, A. (1973), Moses Mendelssohn: A Biographical Study, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
  • Arkush, A. (1994), Moses Mendelssohn and the Enlightenment, State University of New York Press, Albany.
  • Baumgarten, A. (2014), Metaphysics. A Critical Translation with Kant’s Elucidations, Selected Notes and Related Materials, translated and...
  • Beck, L. W. (1969), Early German Philosophy: Kant and His Predecessors, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
  • Beiser, F. C. (1987), The Fate of Reason. German Philosophy from Kant to Fichte, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
  • Dahlstrom, D. O. (2011), “Verbal Disputes in Mendelssohn’s Morgenstunden”, in Moses Mendelssohn’s Metaphysics and Aesthetics, edited by Reinier...
  • Dahlstrom, D. O. (2019), “Truth, Knowledge, and “the Pretentions of Idealism”: A Critical Commentary on the First Part of Mendelssohn’s Morning...
  • Dyck, C. W. (2011), “Turning the Game Against the Idealist: Mendelssohn’s Refutation of Idealism in the Morgenstunden and Kant’s Replies”,...
  • Fogel, J. (2015), “Scepticism of Scepticism: On Mendelssohn’s Philosophy of Common Sense,” Melilah: Manchester Journal of Jewish Studies,...
  • Franks, P (2011), “Divided by Common Sense: Mendelssohn and Jacobi on Reason and Inferential Justification,” in Moses Mendelssohn’s Metaphysics...
  • Freudenthal, G. (2018), “Between Rationalism and Romanticism: Moses Mendelssohn’s Proof of the Existence of God” (Hebrew), In A Tribute to...
  • Freudenthal, G. (2012), No Religion without Idolatry. Mendelssohn’s Jewish Enlightenment, University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame Indiana.
  • Garve, Ch. (1787; 2nd. edition), Philosophische Anmerkungen und Abhandlungen zu Cicero’s Büchern von den Pflichten. Anmerkungen zu dem zweyten...
  • Gottlieb, M. (2011), Faith and Freedom. Moses Mendelssohn’s Theological-Political Thought, Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York.
  • Jakob, L. H. (1786), Prüfung der Mendelssohnschen “Morgenstunden”, Bey Johann Samuel Heinsius, Leipzig.
  • Janke, W. (1989), Petites perceptions, in Historisches Wörterbuch der Philosophie, edited by Joachim Ritter and Karlfried Gründer, Schwabe...
  • Kuehn, M. (1987), Scottish Common Sense in Germany, 1786–1800: A Contribution to the History of Critical Philosophy, Montreal: McGill-Queen’s...
  • Lang, S. (2021), “Mendelssohn und Kant über den ontologischen Gottesbeweis”, Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie, 69, no. 5, pp. 720-741.
  • Leibniz, G. W. (1882), “Nouveaux essais sur l’entendement humain par l’auteur du système de l’harmonie préétablie”, en Die philosophischen...
  • Mendelssohn, M. (1971), “An die Freunde Lessings”, in Gesammelte Schriften: Jubiläumsausgabe (JubA 3.2), edited by Ismar Elbogen, Fritz Bamberger,...
  • Mendelssohn, M. (1983), Jerusalem, or on Religious Power and Judaism, translated by A. Arkush, introduction and commentary by A. Altmann....
  • Mendelssohn, M. (1997), “On Evidence in Metaphysical Sciences”, in Moses Mendelssohn, Philosophical Writings, translated and edited by D....
  • Mendelssohn, M. (2011), Morning Hours: Lectures on God’s Existence, translated by D. O. Dahlstrom and C. Dyck, edited by R. Munk, Dordrecht,...
  • Munk, R. (2011), ““What Is the Bond?” The Discussion of Mendelssohn and Kant 1785–1787”. in Moses Mendelssohn’s Metaphysics and Aesthetics,...
  • Rovira, R. (2017), “Mendelssohn’s Refutation of Kant’s Critique of the Ontological Proof”, Kant-Studien, no. 108, pp. 401–26.
  • Rovira, R. (2023), “Nochmals zu Mendelssohn, Kant und dem ontologischen Gottesbeweis”, Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie, 71, no. 2, pp....
  • Russell, B. (1959), “A Free Man’s Worship”, in Mysticism and Logic and other Essays, George Allen & Unwin LTD, London, pp. 46-57.
  • Sánchez de León Serrano, J. M. (2024), “Unity in Reason: Mendelssohn on the Conflict between Common Sense and Speculation”, Religions 15,...
  • Shaftesbury, Lord [Anthony Ashley Cooper, 3rd Earl of Shaftesbury] (1732), “The Moralists, a Philosophical Rhapsody”, in Characteristicks...
  • Vogt, W. (2005), Moses Mendelssohns Beschreibung der Wirklichkeit menschlichen Erkennens, Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg.
  • Williams, B. (1978), Descartes: The Project of Pure Enquiry, Penguin, Harmondsworth.
  • Wolff, Ch. (1736-37), Theologia naturalis scientifica pertractata, 2 vols., Frankfurt.
  • Wundt, M. (1945), Die deutsche Schulphilosophie im Zeitalter der Aufklärung, G. Olms, Hildesheim.