Kant and the Duty to Stay in the State of Nature

• Slenzok, Norbert ^[1] ; Trzcionka, Patryk ^[2]
  1. [1] University of Zielona Góra

     University of Zielona Góra

     Zielona Góra, Polonia

     
  2. [2] University of Silesia

     University of Silesia

     Katowice, Polonia

     
• Localización: Con-textos Kantianos: International Journal of Philosophy, ISSN-e 2386-7655, Vol. 22, 2025, págs. 121-133
• Idioma: inglés
• DOI: 10.5209/kant.104363
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo (pdf)
• Resumen

  • The paper tackles the question as to whether Kant has successfully substantiated his claim that there exists a moral and juridical duty to leave the state of nature. Our thesis is that he has not. In the first step, it is demonstrated that Kant’s concept of provisional ownership is a logical impossibility. Thus, property rights themselves cannot generate the duty to submit to the state. The only way to argue for the duty to exit statelessness that the Kantian is left with is therefore to conceive of that duty as implied directly by the right to freedom. Yet, one may plausibly argue that at the conceptual level, public law runs afoul of Kant’s notion of freedom to a greater degree than private law does. Therefore, in virtue of the innate right to freedom, a prima facie duty arises to stay in the state of nature.

• Referencias bibliográficas
  • Achenwall, G. (2020), Natural Law: A Translation of the Textbook for Kant’s Lectures on Legal and Political Philosophy, Ed. P. Kleinweld,...
  • Barnett, R.E. (2014), The Structure of Liberty: Justice and the Rule of Law, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • Buchanan, J.M. (1975), The Limits of Liberty. Between Anarchy and Leviathan, The University of Chicago Press: Chicago-London.
  • Buchanan, J.M., Tullock G. (1965), The Calculus of Consent. The Logical Foundations of Constitutional Democracy, Ann Arbor: University of...
  • Buchner, W. (1996), Kant - państwo i prawo, Kraków: Wydawnictwo Aureus.
  • Byrd, B.S., Hruschka, J. (2010), Kant’s Doctrine of Right. A Commentary, New York: Cambridge University Press.
  • Christmas, B. (2021), “Against Kantian Statism”, The Journal of Politics no. 83 (4), pp. 1721-1733.
  • Christmas, B. (2025), “Property, Authority, and Unavoidable Unilateralism”, Law & Philosophy, forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=5200383...
  • Demsetz, H. (1969), “Information and Efficiency: Another Viewpoint”, The Journal of Law & Economics, Apr., 1969, Vol. 12, No. 1 (Apr.,...
  • Flikschuh, K. (2022), “Innate right in Kant—A critical reading”, European Journal of Philosophy, 30(2), pp. 823-839.
  • Fuller, L. (1969), The Morality of Law. Revised Edition, Yale University Press: New Haven and London.
  • Ellis, E. (2008), Provisional Politics. Kantian Arguments in Policy Contexts, New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
  • Gregor, M. J. (1962), Laws of Freedom. A Study of Kant’s Method od Applying the Categorical Imperative in the Metaphysik der Sitten, New York:...
  • Gregory, M.L. (2021), “Kant’s Naturrecht Feyerabend, Achenwall, and the Role of the State”, Kant Yearbook 13 (1), pp. 49-71.
  • Guyer, P. (2000), Kant on Freedom, Law, and Happiness, Cambridge University Press: Edinburgh-New York.
  • Hart, H. (2001), Essays on Bentham. Jurisprudence and Political Theory, Clarendon Press: Oxford.
  • Hasnas, J. (2003), “Reflections on the Minimal State”, Politics, Philosophy and Economics 1(2).
  • Hasnas, J. (2008), “The Obviousness of Anarchy”, In: R.T. Long. T..R. Machan (ed.), Anarchism/Minarchism, Is Government Part of a Free Country?,...
  • Hayek, F.A. (1982), Law, Legislation, and Liberty. A New Statement of the Liberal Principles of Justice and Political Economy, London: Routledge.
  • Hodgson, L-P. (2010), “Kant on Property Rights and the State”, Kantian Review, 15, pp. 57-87.
  • Höffe, O. (2022), Immanuel Kant, C.H. Beck.
  • Hohfeld, W. (1919), Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning and Other Essays, New Haven-London.
  • Honoré, A.M. (1993), “Ownership”, In: Patricia Smith (ed.), The Nature and Process of Law, New York: Oxford University Press.
  • Hoppe, H-H. (2006), The Economics and Ethics of Private Property, Auburn, Ala: The Ludwig von Mises Institute.
  • Hoppe, H-H. (2021), The Great Fiction. Property, Economy, Society, and the Politics of Decline, Auburn, Ala: The Ludwig von Mises Institute.
  • Huemer, M. (2013), The Problem of Political Authority: An Examination of the Right to Coerce and the Duty to Obey, New York: Palgrave MacMillan.
  • Kant, I. (1968), Kant's Political Writings, Edit. Raymond Geuss, Quentin Skinner, Cambridge: Cambridge Texts in the History of Political...
  • Kant, I. (1991), The Metaphysics of Morals, Trans. Mary Gregor. Cambridge-New York-Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.
  • Kant, I. (1998), Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, Trans. M. Gregor, Camridge: Cambridge University Press.
  • Kant, I. (2016), Lectures and Drafts on Political Philosophy, Trans. F. Rauscher, K.R. Westphal, Cambridge University Press.
  • Kinsella, N. S. (1995), “Legislation and the Discovery of Law in a Free Society”, Journal of Libertarian Studies 11:2, pp. 132-181.
  • Kersting, W. (1992), “Politics, Freedom, and Order. Kant’s Political Philosophy”, In: P. Guyer (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Kant, Cambridge...
  • Kramer, M. (2002), “Rights Without Trimmings”, In: M. Kramer, N.E. Simmonds, H. Steiner, A Debate Over Rights. Philosophical Inquiries, New...
  • Kuznicki, J. (2016), “Kantianism”, In: A.R. Powell, G. Babcock (eds.), Arguments for Liberty, Washington DC: Cato Institute.
  • Lakatos, I. (1981), “History of Science and Its Rational Reconstructions”, In: E. Hacking (ed.), Scientific Revolutions, Oxford: Oxford University...
  • Leoni, B. (1972), Freedom and the Law, Los Angeles: Nash Publishing.
  • Linsbichler, A. (2017), Was Ludwig von Mises a Conventionalist? A New Analysis of the Epistemology of the Austrian School of Economics, Palgrave...
  • Locke, J. (1988), Two Treatises of Government, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  • Long, R.T. (2008), “Market Anarchism as Constitutionalism”, In: R.T. Long, T..R. Machan (eds), Anarchism/Minarchism, Is Government Part of...
  • Long, R.T. & Machan T. (eds). 2008, Anarchism/Minarchism. Is Government Part of a Free Country?, Aldershot UK, Burlington USA: Ashgate.
  • Mearsheimer, J. J. (2001), The Tragedy of Great Power Politics, W.W. Norton & Co.
  • Nozick, R. (1999), Anarchy, State, and Utopia, Blackwell: Oxford UK, Cambridge USA.
  • Nye, J.S. (2007), Understanding Global Conflicts. An Introduction to Theory and History, Boston, MA: Pearson.
  • Olson, M. (1971), The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups, Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press.
  • Ripstein, A. (2009), Freedom and Force. Kant’s Legal and Political Philosophy, Cambridge, MA – London: Harvard University Press.
  • Robbins, L. (1932), An Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economic Science. London: MacMillan.
  • Rothbard, M.N. (1998), The Ethics of Liberty, New York: New York University Press.
  • Rothbard, M.N. (2000), The Irrepressible Rothbard. The Rothbard-Rockwell Report Essays of Murray N. Rothbard, Burlingame, CA: The Center for...
  • Sangiovanni, A. (2012), Can the Innate Right to Freedom Alone Ground a System of Public and Private Rights?, European Journal of Philosophy,...
  • Simmonds, N.E. (2002), “Rights at the Cutting Edge”, In: M. Kramer, N.E. Simmonds, H. Steiner, A Debate Over Rights. Philosophical Inquiries,...
  • Steiner, H. (1994), An Essay on Rights, Blackwell: Oxford UK and Cambridge USA.
  • Steiner, H. (2002), “Working Rights.” In: M. Kramer, N.E. Simmonds, H. Steiner, A Debate Over Rights. Philosophical Inquiries, New York: Oxford...
  • Stilz, A. (2014), “Provisional Rights and Non-state Peoples”, In: Kant and Colonialism, Oxford, edited by Katrin Flikschuh and Lea Ypi, Oxford...
  • Stone, M. J., Hasan, R. (2022), What Is Provisional Right?, Philosophical Review, 131(1); pp. 51-98.
  • Stringham, E. (2015), Private Governance. Creating Order in Economic and Social Life, New York: Oxford University Press.
  • Stringham, E. (ed.). 2018, Anarchy, State, and Public Choice. Advanced Studies in Political Economy. Arlington VA: Mercatus Center.
  • Szczepański, J. (2017), Filozofia polityczna Immanuela Kanta, Kraków: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego.
  • Szczepański, J. (2019), Metamorfoza: Immanuel Kant o przemianie politycznej w ujęciu teleologicznym, Kraków: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego.
  • Thomas, W. R. (2008), “Objectivism against Anarchy”, In: Long, R.T. & Machan T. (eds), Anarchism/Minarchism. Is Government Part of a Free...
  • Thorpe, L., Demirli, S. (2024), Three aspects of Kantian Autonomy: Independence, Self-Determination and Citizenship. Con-Textos Kantianos....
  • Thrasher, J. (2019), “Self-ownership as personal sovereignty”, Social Philosophy & Policy, 36(2), pp. 116–133, https://doi.org/10.1017/S0265052519000396...
  • Von Savigny, F. C. (1979), Treatise on Possession; or, the Jus Possessionis of the Civil Law, Westport: Hyperion Press.
  • Van der Vossen, B. (2015), “Imposing Duties and Original Appropriation”, Journal of Political Philosophy 23:64-85.
  • Varden, H. (2008), “Kant's Non-Voluntarist Conception of Political Obligations: Why Justice is Impossible in the State of Nature”, Kantian...
  • Varden, H. (2010), “Kant’s Non-Absolutist Conception of Political Legitimacy – How Public Right ‘Concludes’ Private Right in the ‘Doctrine...
  • Verhaegh, M. (2004), “Kant and Property Rights”, The Journal of Libertarian Studies 18, no. 3.
  • Weber, M. (2004), The Vocation Lectures: Science as a Vocation, Politics as a Vocation. Trans. R. Livingstone, Indianapolis/Cambridge: Hackett...
  • Williams, H. (1977), “Kant’s Concept of Property”, The Philosophical Quarterly, Vol. 27, No. 106, pp. 32-40.
  • Waldron, J. (1996), “Kant’s Legal Positivism.” Harvard Law Review 109:1535-66.
  • Wood, A. (2007), Kantian Ethics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
  • Wood, A. (2014), The Free Development of Each. Studies on Freedom, Right, and Ethics in Classical German Philosophy. New York: Oxford University...